ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Beauty Brands Face Consumer Backlash Over Identical Eye Patch Launches

other · 2026-10-05

The recent launch of nearly identical undereye masks by Fenty, Glow Recipe, and Huda Beauty, featuring the same packaging and dispensing design, has ignited a controversy dubbed "Eye Patch Gate" on social media. This situation raises questions about brands utilizing the same manufacturers. As consumers become more discerning due to geopolitical tensions and rising inflation, they demand authenticity and tangible results. According to McKinsey, the beauty sector is anticipated to expand by 5% annually until 2030. Sam Cheow from Stealth Advisory remarked on how informed consumers scrutinize marketing messages. Charlotte Palermino of Dieux Skin expressed skepticism about product innovation, while Eran Rosman of Noon Aesthetics called for genuine advancements. Dr. Joshua Britton from Debut criticized the reuse of outdated ingredients. Meanwhile, Image Skincare introduced a product with EDL, demonstrating a 100% improvement in fine lines in a clinical trial.

Key facts

  • Fenty, Glow Recipe, and Huda Beauty launched near-identical undereye masks within days of each other
  • The products used the same container and a mechanism that slices a fresh eye patch when dispensed
  • Social media dubbed the coincidence "Eye Patch Gate"
  • McKinsey data projects 5% year-on-year beauty industry growth through 2030
  • Noon Aesthetics launched in the US in 2020 after four years of R&D and holds three patents including DermShield
  • Noon's Lacto line uses a 15% concentration of lactic acid
  • Debut developed the patented EDL ingredient using AI-powered genomic mapping, achieving a 100% fine-line improvement rate in a 12-week clinical study
  • Image Skincare released its first product formulated with EDL this year

Entities

Artists

  • Sam Cheow
  • Charlotte Palermino
  • Eran Rosman
  • Joshua Britton
  • Lisa Eldridge
  • Violette
  • Katie Jane Hughes

Institutions

  • Fenty
  • Glow Recipe
  • Huda Beauty
  • McKinsey
  • Stealth Advisory & Brands
  • L'Oréal
  • Estée Lauder
  • Dieux Skin
  • Noon Aesthetics
  • Debut
  • Image Skincare
  • Lisa Eldridge Beauty
  • Violette
  • Kjh.brand
  • TikTok
  • Vogue

Locations

  • Seoul
  • South Korea
  • United States

Sources