Why Odysseus Bound Himself Before the Sirens
In Homer's Odyssey, Odysseus orders his crew to tie him to the mast and plug their ears with wax to survive the Sirens' song. The enchantress Circe warns him of the Sirens' irresistible, truth-telling song that lures victims to their death. Odysseus chooses to hear the song while bound, a strategy of precommitment to overcome his own future weakness. The concept of precommitment, formalized by economists Thomas Schelling and R.H. Strotz and philosopher Jon Elster in his 1979 work "Ulysses and the Sirens," describes binding oneself to prevent future actions from derailing current preferences. Real-world examples include fixed savings accounts and Ulysses Contracts in medicine. Research from Kellogg School of Management shows most people overestimate their self-restraint, a bias called "restraint bias." Philosophers like Kant and the Stoics interpret Odysseus's binding as an exercise of freedom through self-imposed constraint. Kant argues that following desire is slavery, while the higher self defines freedom. Epictetus states freedom comes from destroying desire, not satisfying it. Odysseus's wisdom lies not in conquering temptation in the moment but in knowing when to tie himself to the mast.
Key facts
- Odysseus tied himself to the mast to hear the Sirens' song safely.
- Circe warned Odysseus about the Sirens and instructed him on how to survive.
- The Sirens' song promised knowledge, not sexual intimacy.
- Precommitment is a psychological strategy to protect future actions from current desires.
- Jon Elster's 1979 book 'Ulysses and the Sirens' uses the myth as a prime example of precommitment.
- Thomas Schelling and R.H. Strotz introduced the concept of precommitment.
- Kellogg School of Management research found people overestimate their self-restraint (restraint bias).
- Kant and Stoics view Odysseus's binding as an exercise of freedom through constraint.
Entities
Artists
- Herbert James Draper
- Jan van Bijlert
- Otto Greiner
- John William Waterhouse
- William Etty
- William Sonmans
- Michael Burghers
Institutions
- Kellogg School of Management
- Manchester Art Gallery
- Ferens Art Gallery
- Google Art Project
- Bridgeman Art Library
- Web Gallery of Art
Locations
- Greece