Screamo in Coffee Shops and Pizza Joints: A Critic's Case Against Loud Music in Food Service
In a first-person essay for Ravenous, Courtney E. Smith recounts visits to two Texas food spots where aggressive music dominated the dining experience. At Stranded Coffee in San Antonio in 2024, a now-closed shop with a spring menu of orange-infused drinks, she encountered second-wave screamo from the 2000s—comparable to Hawthorne Heights and Senses Fail—blasting at 9-something a.m. Staff sang along silently, suggesting personal preference rather than a strategy to turn tables. Months later at Talespin Pizza in Houston, a takeout-focused neo-Neapolitan spot with only two high-top tables, the same genre played at high volume. Smith argues that screamo's high-pitched fry screams and false chord screams produce 95 to 105 dB, comparable to a power lawn mower or a car horn, risking hearing damage. She cites music psychology: soothing songs in grocery stores, jazz in fine dining, and Starbucks' choice of Beck and Norah Jones over Sonic Youth. High-arousal music triggers the sympathetic nervous system, raising heart rates and making waits feel longer, which can alienate customers and increase staff stress. She concludes that quick-service spots should separate kitchen music tastes from the dining area and choose genres that do not drive customers away.
Key facts
- Courtney E. Smith visited San Antonio in 2024 to explore its food scene and found a vibrant coffee house culture tied to six colleges and four community college systems.
- Stranded Coffee, now closed, featured a spring menu with orange-infused coffee options and a mostly patio seating area with cream walls and terracotta orange cups.
- At Stranded Coffee, second-wave screamo from the 2000s, akin to Hawthorne Heights and Senses Fail, was playing loudly at 9-something a.m., with staff singing along.
- Talespin Pizza in Houston, a neo-Neapolitan-style spot with only two high-top tables and a takeout focus, also blasted screamo music.
- Screamo vocals using fry screams and false chord screams reach 95 to 105 dB, while normal speech is 60 to 75 dB and soft rock averages 70 to 85 dB.
- Classically trained opera singers produce 95 to 105 dB, and 100 to 115 dB is equivalent to a power lawn mower or a car horn.
- Music can manipulate consumer moods: grocery stores play soothing songs, fine dining plays jazz or classical, and Starbucks opted for Beck and Norah Jones over Sonic Youth.
- High-arousal music with fast tempo and strong beats triggers the sympathetic nervous system, increasing heart rate and making waits seem longer and more aggravating.
Entities
Artists
- Courtney E. Smith
- Geoff Rickley
- Richard Wagner
- Richard Strauss
- Bon Iver
- Christopher Cross
- Beck
- Norah Jones
Institutions
- Ravenous
- Stranded Coffee
- Talespin Pizza
- Hawthorne Heights
- Senses Fail
- Thursday
- Cursive
- Sonic Youth
- Starbucks
- Kuma's Corner
Locations
- San Antonio
- United States
- Houston
- Texas
- Chicago