Keith Haring Drawing Ruled Authentic but Unsellable at Top Auction Houses
A Connecticut court has ruled that a Keith Haring drawing featuring flying saucers is indeed authentic. However, Christie's and Sotheby's can't auction it because the provenance isn't solid enough. Vernon Hartung, a Nevada businessman, bought the piece for $165,000 from Martin Lawrence Galleries back in 2018. When he tried to sell it through the auction houses, both turned it down, citing a lack of proper documentation. Martin Lawrence Galleries then attempted to sell it for him but received offers between $20,000 and $30,000, which Hartung felt were too low. He ended up suing the gallery for breach of contract and unfair trade practices. In May, Judge Robert L. Genuario confirmed the drawing's authenticity but ruled against Hartung, stating he couldn't prove any wrongdoing by the gallery, resulting in him having to pay the gallery's legal fees. This highlights the gap between what courts consider authentic and what auction houses require.
Key facts
- Keith Haring drawing of flying saucers deemed authentic by a Connecticut Superior Court judge.
- Drawing purchased by Vernon Hartung from Martin Lawrence Galleries for $165,000 in 2018.
- Christie's and Sotheby's refused to sell the drawing due to insufficient provenance records.
- Martin Lawrence Galleries attempted to sell the work for Hartung, with offers ranging from $20,000 to $30,000.
- Hartung sued the gallery for breach of contract and violations of the Connecticut Unfair Trade Practices Act.
- Judge Robert L. Genuario ruled the drawing authentic based on a 2002 letter from Richard Hambleton.
- Hartung lost the case and was ordered to pay the defendant's attorney's fees.
- The case illustrates the gap between legal authenticity and auction house provenance standards.
Entities
Artists
- Keith Haring
- Richard Hambleton
Institutions
- Christie's
- Sotheby's
- Martin Lawrence Galleries
- Martin Lawrence Gallery
Locations
- Connecticut
- Nevada
Sources
- Artslife —
- Robb Report —