J.D. Vance's Conversion Memoir 'Communion' Criticized as Contemptuous and Opportunistic

On June 16th, J.D. Vance released his second memoir, 'Communion: Finding My Way Back to Faith,' which has faced backlash for its perceived lack of spiritual insight and disdain for Catholicism. The narrative explores Vance's tumultuous upbringing in Baptist and Pentecostal traditions, his youthful atheism, and his Catholic baptism at thirty-five. Critics argue that he exhibits more disdain for Catholic practices, such as confession and the Eucharist, rather than genuine respect. The book outlines how a 2011 speech by tech mogul Peter Thiel at Yale Law School influenced his conversion, with Thiel later supporting Vance's political ambitions. While Vance’s Senate campaign is described as a 'quirky intellectual project' advocating Christian economic views, his voting history suggests otherwise. His planned 2025 visit to the Vatican and discussions with Pope Francis about immigration highlight a disconnect between his political views and Catholic teachings. Observers note Vance's 'essential mutability' and careerism, contrasting his admiration for his grandmother Mamaw with his shallow understanding of Catholic theology, suggesting the memoir aims to placate his evangelical supporters amid his conversion journey.