French Senate Bill Would Expand State Control Over Privately Owned Art
In March 2026, Senator Jacques Grosperrin proposed legislation in the French Senate aimed at broadening the definition of trésor national to encompass artworks by French artists from any era, thereby increasing governmental oversight over private collections and sales. This initiative builds upon the Code du patrimoine, which permits the state to prohibit exports for a period of 30 months without offering compensation. Notable recent inclusions feature Gustave Caillebotte's Boulevard vu d'en haut (1880) designated in February 2026. The 2019 incident involving Rembrandt’s The Standard Bearer (1636) illustrates potential challenges. Meanwhile, the UK's export restriction on Rembrandt's Portrait of Catrina Hooghsaet (1657) functions consistently. The classification of Hans Baldung Grien's Portrait of Susanna Pfeffinger (1517) in March 2026 has ignited legal discussions, with critics cautioning that the bill could negatively impact the contemporary art scene.
Key facts
- Senator Jacques Grosperrin introduced a bill in the French Senate in March 2026 to expand the definition of trésor national to works by French artists regardless of age.
- The bill would extend state pre-emption to private transactions beyond auction houses.
- Gustave Caillebotte's Boulevard vu d'en haut (1880) was designated a trésor national in February 2026, with export barred until August 2028.
- France blocked the sale of Rembrandt's The Standard Bearer (1636) in 2019 for €165m but failed to raise the funds, and the painting went to the Rijksmuseum in 2021.
- The UK placed an export bar on Rembrandt's Portrait of Catrina Hooghsaet (1657), valued at £71m, with a deferral expiring on 26 December.
- Hans Baldung Grien's Portrait of Susanna Pfeffinger (1517) was classified a trésor national in March 2026 after being withdrawn from a sale at Drouot, despite no export attempt.
- In the Brimo de Laroussilhe case, the Paris Administrative Court sided with the state in 2017 over a sculpted fragment from Chartres Cathedral, and the Conseil d'État upheld the ruling three years later.
- The president of Cambi Casa d'Aste estimates export restrictions can cut a work's value by 70% to 80%.
Entities
Artists
- Jacques Grosperrin
- Gustave Caillebotte
- Rembrandt
- Hans Baldung Grien
Institutions
- French Senate
- Rijksmuseum
- Drouot
- Cambi Casa d'Aste
- Brimo de Laroussilhe
- Paris Administrative Court
- Conseil d'État
Locations
- France
- Netherlands
- United Kingdom
- Italy
- Chartres
- Paris