Federal Judge Blocks Key Parts of Trump's Election Executive Order
A federal judge in Massachusetts blocked sections of President Donald Trump's executive order targeting mail-in voting and voter registration. District Judge Indira Talwani struck down Section 2, which required the Department of Homeland Security to create 'confirmed citizen lists,' and Section 3, which directed the US Postal Service to limit ballot mailing. She also invalidated Section 5, which mandated record preservation and enforcement of federal election laws, calling it 'merely precatory.' Talwani ruled that the president lacks constitutional authority over elections, which are reserved to states and Congress. The decision follows a separate ruling earlier in the week blocking another Trump election order. State attorneys general, including New York's Letitia James and California's Rob Bonta, praised the ruling. Voting rights groups such as the League of Women Voters and the ACLU also challenged the order. White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson vowed to continue the fight, citing the proposed SAVE America Act. Trump canceled a signing ceremony for a bipartisan housing bill, demanding passage of the SAVE Act.
Key facts
- Judge Indira Talwani blocked Sections 2, 3, and 5 of Trump's executive order.
- Section 2 required DHS to create 'confirmed citizen lists' of eligible voters.
- Section 3 directed USPS to limit ballot mailing to voters not on its lists.
- Section 5 mandated record preservation and enforcement of federal election laws.
- Talwani ruled the order violates separation of powers and is ultra vires.
- The ruling follows another decision earlier in the week blocking a separate Trump election order.
- State attorneys general from New York, California, and others supported the challenge.
- White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson said the administration will continue to fight.
- Trump canceled a housing bill signing ceremony, demanding passage of the SAVE America Act.
Entities
Institutions
- US Department of Homeland Security
- US Postal Service
- Department of Justice
- White House
- Common Dreams
- Naked Capitalism
- Association of Americans Resident Overseas
- Delta Sigma Theta Sorority
- League of Women Voters
- LWV of Massachusetts
- OCA – Asian Pacific American Advocates
- US Vote Foundation
- ACLU
- Asian Americans Advancing Justice
- Brennan Center for Justice
- Legal Defense Fund
- LatinoJustice PRLDEF
- Congress
- US Supreme Court
- Democratic-led states
- voting rights groups
Locations
- Massachusetts
- United States
- District of Massachusetts
- Boston