ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Essay Argues AI Writing Detection Turns Readers and Writers Into Adversaries

opinion-review · 2026-10-13

A piece published by The Walrus contends that readers who believe they can reliably identify AI-generated writing are mistaken, and that the attempt to do so is reshaping reading habits. According to the essay, the pursuit of spotting machine-written text has made readers skeptical, antagonistic, and less inclined to extend the benefit of the doubt to fellow humans. The author, described as a writer, frames the dynamic as one in which writer and reader are turned into adversaries. The essay positions the question of what AI writing looks like as a force that is transforming everyone into a different kind of reader. The Walrus published the piece, which carries the title "Think You Can Spot AI Writing? Probably Not." The article was surfaced through ArtsJournal's Belknap feed, which linked to the original Walrus URL.

Key facts

  • The Walrus published an essay titled "Think You Can Spot AI Writing? Probably Not."
  • The essay argues readers who think they can detect AI writing are wrong.
  • The piece says the question of what AI writing looks like is turning people into different kinds of readers.
  • Readers are described as skeptical, antagonistic, and less willing to give fellow humans the benefit of the doubt.
  • The author says trying to determine what AI writing looks like turns writer and reader into adversaries.
  • The author is identified as a writer and promises to explain why.
  • The article was distributed via an ArtsJournal Belknap feed link to thewalrus.ca.
  • The source URL is https://thewalrus.ca/readers-think-they-can-spot-ai-writing-theyre-wrong.

Entities

Institutions

  • The Walrus
  • ArtsJournal

Sources