ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Attention spans are shrinking, but willpower alone won't fix it

opinion-review · 2026-06-20

A recent article in Il Post examines the decline of sustained attention in the digital age, citing research by psychologist Gloria Mark of Columbia University. Mark found that average focus time on screens dropped from 2.5 minutes in 2004 to 47 seconds after the pandemic. Comedian Mattia Alfieri's Instagram post about preferring to stare into space rather than scroll exemplifies the paradox of instant gratification versus wasted time. The piece argues that tech companies have turned attention into a commodity, using design tricks to keep users engaged. Johann Hari's book "Stolen Focus" is referenced, claiming that promoting self-control as a solution is a form of "cruel optimism" as defined by cultural critic Lauren Berlant. The article notes that structural changes to business models—subscriptions, public ownership—could reduce incentives for sensationalism, but companies would lose money. It concludes that without economic restructuring, the problem will persist.

Key facts

  • Gloria Mark of Columbia University measured attention spans: 2.5 minutes in 2004, 1 minute 15 seconds in 2012, 47 seconds after the pandemic.
  • Comedian Mattia Alfieri posted on Instagram about preferring to stare into space rather than scroll.
  • Katherine Hayles' 2017 book 'The Unthought' describes a shift from prolonged attention to hyper-attention.
  • A 2023 study found that the mere presence of a smartphone in the room worsened concentration test results.
  • Johann Hari's book 'Stolen Focus' argues tech companies promote self-control as a solution, calling it 'cruel optimism'.
  • Lauren Berlant coined the term 'cruel optimism' for offering individual solutions to systemic problems.
  • The article suggests subscriptions or public ownership could reduce incentives for attention-grabbing content.
  • TikTok videos under one minute get the most views and interactions.

Entities

Artists

  • Mattia Alfieri
  • Gloria Mark
  • Katherine Hayles
  • Johann Hari
  • Lauren Berlant
  • Derek Thompson
  • Raymond Williams

Institutions

  • Columbia University
  • Il Post
  • The Atlantic
  • Washington Post

Locations

  • Ankara
  • Turkey
  • Helsinki
  • Finland
  • Jerez de la Frontera
  • Spain
  • Toledo
  • Ohio
  • Berlin
  • Germany

Sources