Wim Wenders questions altering problematic film scenes at German Film Awards
At the German Film Awards gala, Wim Wenders, honored for lifetime achievement, called for a debate on how to handle problematic film scenes, referencing Nastassja Kinski's request to edit a scene from his 1975 film 'Falsche Bewegung' where she appeared topless at age 13. Kinski, who has sought the edit for 15 years with legal help, described the experience as traumatic. Wenders admitted he would not film such a scene today but has refused to alter the film, citing archival integrity. He contrasted this with Steven Spielberg's digital retouches in 'E.T.' and noted his own alterations to 'Die Angst des Tormanns beim Elfmeter' for commercial reasons, where music was replaced due to rights issues. Wenders suggested limiting original distribution to museums as a compromise. The speech followed his earlier controversial advice at the Berlinale for filmmakers to stay out of politics.
Key facts
- Wim Wenders spoke at the German Film Awards (Lola) about editing problematic film scenes.
- Nastassja Kinski requested removal of a topless scene from 'Falsche Bewegung' (1975), filmed when she was 13.
- Kinski has sought the edit for 15 years, with legal assistance.
- Wenders said he would not film such a scene today but has refused to alter the film.
- He cited Steven Spielberg's digital retouches in 'E.T.' as an example of post-release alteration.
- Wenders previously altered 'Die Angst des Tormanns beim Elfmeter' by replacing music due to rights issues.
- He suggested limiting distribution of the original to museums as a possible solution.
- Wenders' speech followed his Berlinale advice for filmmakers to avoid politics.
Entities
Artists
- Wim Wenders
- Nastassja Kinski
- Rüdiger Vogler
- Barbara Loden
- Steven Spielberg
- Michael Beckmann
Institutions
- German Film Awards
- Berlinale
- Süddeutsche Zeitung
- ARD
- Deutsches Filmmuseum Frankfurt
- Wim Wenders Stiftung
Locations
- Germany