ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Why Rothko Resonates but Stockhausen Doesn't: Art vs. Music Accessibility

opinion-review · 2026-05-05

David Stubbs' book 'Fear of Music' questions why Rothko's paintings are widely embraced while Stockhausen's avant-garde music remains obscure, attributing this to visual media's dominance. Peter Vergo's 'The Music of Painting' (2010) explores historical intersections between visual and sonic arts. Mariella Milan's 'Milioni a colori' (2015) examines how Italian rotocalchi (magazines) shaped public taste for contemporary art between 1960-1964. A 1963 Epoca contest offered paintings by Guttuso, Carrà, Sironi, and others to readers, illustrating art's commodification. The article contrasts this with a hypothetical music contest featuring composers like Berio and Nono, suggesting public indifference. Vincenzo Santarcangelo, author and professor at Politecnico di Torino and IED Milano, argues that images as merchandise have greater cultural penetration than sound.

Key facts

  • David Stubbs' book 'Fear of Music' compares public reception of Rothko and Stockhausen.
  • Peter Vergo's 'The Music of Painting' was published in 2010.
  • Mariella Milan's 'Milioni a colori' focuses on Italian rotocalchi from 1960-1964.
  • Epoca magazine held a contest on May 9, 1963, offering paintings by ten 20th-century artists.
  • The contest artists included Renato Guttuso, Carlo Carrà, Mario Sironi, and Filippo De Pisis.
  • The article hypothesizes a similar music contest with composers like Berio and Nono would fail.
  • Vincenzo Santarcangelo teaches at Politecnico di Torino and IED Milano.
  • The article was published in Artribune Magazine #29.

Entities

Artists

  • David Stubbs
  • Mark Rothko
  • Karlheinz Stockhausen
  • Peter Vergo
  • Mariella Milan
  • Renato Guttuso
  • Umberto Lilloni
  • Carlo Carrà
  • Mario Sironi
  • Fiorenzo Tomea
  • Pio Semeghini
  • Domenico Cantatore
  • Aligi Sassu
  • Orfeo Tamburi
  • Filippo De Pisis
  • Ottorino Respighi
  • Ildebrando Pizzetti
  • Luigi Dallapiccola
  • Gian Francesco Malipiero
  • Goffredo Petrassi
  • Luciano Berio
  • Bruno Maderna
  • Luigi Nono
  • Franco Donatoni
  • Vincenzo Santarcangelo
  • Paul Klee
  • Pierre Boulez

Institutions

  • Melody Maker
  • Artribune
  • Politecnico di Torino
  • IED Milano
  • LabOnt (Università di Torino)
  • Epoca
  • Amadeus

Locations

  • Italy
  • Milan
  • Turin

Sources