ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Vox pops are mostly useless, says Cardiff University study

opinion-review · 2026-05-25

A Cardiff University study criticizes broadcasters' over-reliance on vox pops during the UK's recent local elections, noting they take up airtime at the expense of policy coverage and scrutiny. The term 'vox pop' derives from 'Vox populi, vox dei,' but Alcuin of York originally warned Charlemagne that 'the tumult of the crowd is always close to madness.' Vox pops are dominated by those willing to stop for cameras, can be edited to fit any narrative, and ignore that many people know little about the subject. The article suggests requiring reporters to first establish interviewees' baseline expertise, such as asking about council responsibilities or local councillors, before broadcasting their opinions.

Key facts

  • Cardiff University study examined TV news coverage of UK local elections.
  • Study found over-reliance on vox pops at expense of policy coverage.
  • Term 'vox pop' abbreviates 'Vox populi, vox dei' (voice of the people is voice of God).
  • Alcuin of York warned Charlemagne against listening to those who say that phrase.
  • Vox pops are dominated by people willing to stop for cameras.
  • Vox pops can be edited to fit any narrative.
  • Article suggests requiring baseline expertise questions before broadcasting vox pops.
  • Examples of questions: list three statutory responsibilities of local council, name local councillor.

Entities

Institutions

  • Cardiff University
  • Monocle

Locations

  • Wales
  • United Kingdom
  • Belgium
  • Iran
  • Denmark
  • York
  • Europe

Sources