ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Valeria Luiselli on Mexico City's Impossible Map

publication · 2026-04-27

In an essay published on Artribune, writer Valeria Luiselli reflects on the impossibility of mapping Mexico City, describing it as a 'pure nostalgia for the future.' Drawing on Borges and Mark Fisher's hauntology, she argues that residents sense urban planning was never more than a sketch, leaving them to inhabit 'the ruins of an oversized map.' The article, by Leonardo Merlini, connects this to a giant map of Venice in Palazzo Balbi that attempts to depict every building, highlighting the failure of any narrative to capture such cities. Luiselli notes that writing about Mexico City is doomed from the start, as the city resembles nothing but a stain—like the humidity mark on an altar that supposedly formed the Virgin of Guadalupe, or the footprints left by characters in Roberto Bolaño's 'The Savage Detectives.' She compares these to the marks left when a painting is removed from a wall or the shadows of bodies disintegrated by a nuclear explosion. The piece is part of Artribune Magazine #54 and promotes Luiselli's book 'Carte false' (La Nuova Frontiera, 2020).

Key facts

  • Valeria Luiselli describes Mexico City as a 'pure nostalgia for the future.'
  • She references Borges and Mark Fisher's hauntology.
  • Luiselli says residents feel urban planning was only a sketch.
  • The phrase 'ruins of an oversized map' is used.
  • Leonardo Merlini compares this to a giant map of Venice in Palazzo Balbi.
  • Luiselli claims writing about Mexico City is impossible.
  • She compares the city to a stain, like the Virgin of Guadalupe apparition or footprints in Bolaño's novel.
  • The article appears in Artribune Magazine #54 and promotes 'Carte false' (2020).

Entities

Artists

  • Valeria Luiselli
  • Leonardo Merlini
  • Jorge Luis Borges
  • Mark Fisher
  • Roberto Bolaño
  • Mara Font
  • Juan García Madero

Institutions

  • Artribune
  • La Nuova Frontiera
  • Palazzo Balbi
  • Regione Veneto

Locations

  • Mexico City
  • Venice
  • Distrito Federal
  • Rome

Sources