The art market's crisis of speculation, fraud, and the need for reform
An in-depth examination of the modern art market indicates it functions as a speculative sector, disconnected from genuine artistic merit and rife with bureaucracy, deception, and opacity. It highlights the historical connections among art, finance, and politics, dating back to figures like the Medici and Napoleon, and references Ai Weiwei's assertion that "everything is art, everything is politics." Since the 1980s, the art market has evolved into a spectacle-driven industry, reflecting Thorstein Veblen's 1899 concept of conspicuous consumption and Yves Klein's 1957 show that showcased arbitrary valuations. The Panama Papers unveiled dishonest art transactions, while Brexit and global instability contributed to a 30% drop in sales at Christie's in H1 2016. The analysis advocates for financial reforms and a shift back to viewing art as an emotional experience rather than merely a secure asset.
Key facts
- Christie's sales fell 30% in first half of 2016, nearly $1.5 billion.
- Sotheby's sales dropped over 20% in the same period.
- Knoedler Gallery closed after over 100 years due to a forgery scandal involving Glafira Rosales.
- In Italy, 400 galleries have closed in recent years.
- Yves Klein's 1957 exhibition 'L'epoca blu' at Galleria Apollinaire in Milan sold identical monochromes at different prices.
- Panama Papers revealed fraudulent use of art in opaque deals and free ports.
- Thorstein Veblen's 1899 book 'Theory of the Leisure Class' argued that ostentation determines value.
- Ai Weiwei stated 'everything is art, everything is politics' in 'Weiweismi' (Einaudi, 2013).
Entities
Artists
- Ai Weiwei
- Yves Klein
- Thorstein Veblen
- Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
- Dino Buzzati
- Nicola Gardini
- Franco Broccardi
- Alexander Calder
- Ernst Beyeler
- Han van Meegeren
- Amedeo Modigliani
- Napoleon Bonaparte
- Augustus
- Gaius Maecenas
- Hermann Göring
Institutions
- Artribune
- Christie's
- Sotheby's
- Knoedler Art Gallery
- Galleria Apollinaire
- Corriere d'Informazione
- Fondazione Cini
- ANGAMC
- Federculture
- ICOM
- Einaudi
- Gallimard
- Ricciardi
- Garzanti
Locations
- Italy
- New York
- Milan
- Rotterdam
- Venice
- Livorno