Smithsonian's National Museum of Asian Art Criticized for Western-Centric Framing
A critical review of the Smithsonian Institution's National Museum of Asian Art in Washington, DC, argues that the institution perpetuates a Western-centric view of Asia. The museum, comprising the Freer Gallery of Art (opened 1923) and the Arthur M. Sackler Gallery (1982), was rebranded in 2019 as the National Museum of Asian Art. The review highlights a press conference for the Centennial Asian Pacific American Heritage Month Festival in May, featuring Filipino food and K-pop, which the author describes as superficial. The museum's collections, built on the foundations of Charles Lang Freer and Arthur Sackler, are critiqued for Euro-American biases. Freer's collection, described by academic Kin-Yee Ian Shin, exemplifies late-19th-century American efforts to establish authority over Asian art. The current exhibition 'Freer's Global Network' (2022–) attempts to address criticism but fails to acknowledge the power dynamics. Displays like 'Body Image: Arts of the Indian Subcontinent' (2017–) and 'Prehistoric Spirals: Earthenware from Thailand' (2021–) are cited as reinforcing stereotypes. The museum's focus on pre-20th-century objects limits engagement with contemporary Asia. Deputy director Lori Duggan Gold and head of public programmes Nicole Dowd are mentioned. Director Chase F. Robinson stated the museum played a role in 'determining the canon' of Asian art.
Key facts
- National Museum of Asian Art in Washington, DC, comprises Freer Gallery (1923) and Arthur M. Sackler Gallery (1982).
- Rebranded in 2019 to emphasize Asian art focus.
- Centennial Asian Pacific American Heritage Month Festival in May included Filipino food and K-pop.
- Charles Lang Freer bequeathed 9,420 works; Arthur Sackler donated 1,000 objects.
- Exhibition 'Freer's Global Network' (2022–) addresses criticism of white collecting.
- Displays like 'Body Image: Arts of the Indian Subcontinent' (2017–) and 'Prehistoric Spirals' (2021–) criticized for stereotypes.
- Museum's collection exceeds 46,000 objects, mostly pre-20th century.
- Academic Kin-Yee Ian Shin described Freer's collection as establishing American authority on Asian art.
Entities
Artists
- Charles Lang Freer
- Arthur M. Sackler
- James McNeill Whistler
- Bunkio Matsuki
- Dikran Kelekian
- Langdon Warner
- Frederick McCormick
- Emma Natalya Stein
- Aparna Sadananda
- Chase F. Robinson
- Nicole Dowd
- Lori Duggan Gold
- Kin-Yee Ian Shin
Institutions
- Smithsonian Institution
- National Museum of Asian Art
- Freer Gallery of Art
- Arthur M. Sackler Gallery
- Purdue Pharma
Locations
- Washington, DC
- United States
- National Mall
- China
- Korea
- Japan
- Philippines
- Thailand
- India
- Southeast Asia