Shelter Island Travel Guide: Where to Stay, Eat, and Visit
Nestled between the Hamptons and North Fork, Shelter Island is reachable solely by ferry, which adds to its tranquil appeal. The island has welcomed several new dining and lodging options, such as The Boathouse, a three-bedroom rental boasting harbor views, a hot tub, and a sauna. The Pridwin, which underwent renovations in 2022, features 33 rooms and 16 cottages, with a cocktail menu curated by NYC's Dante team. The Chequit includes an Italian eatery and a charterable sailboat from 1926. Sevens B&B offers seven king rooms and a heated pool, while Vine Street bistro focuses on local produce. Other notable restaurants are The Dory, Léon 1909, Opties and Dinghies, Blue Han, and Peeko's. Outdoor activities and shopping can be enjoyed at Mashomack Preserve and Sylvester Manor.
Key facts
- Shelter Island is accessible only by ferry.
- The Boathouse is a rental from Boutique Homes, furnished with Design Within Reach.
- The Pridwin was built in the 1920s and renovated in 2022.
- The Chequit's hotel group owns a 1926 sailboat.
- Vine Street is open year-round and offers a Monday bouillabaisse.
- Léon 1909 is a French-Italian restaurant with an open hearth.
- Blue Han is a new Korean kitchen and cafe.
- SPRMRKT is a streetwear shop inside the island's only grocery store, founded by Anthony Peronace.
Entities
Artists
- Anthony Peronace
Institutions
- Boutique Homes
- Design Within Reach
- The Pridwin
- The Chequit
- Sevens
- Vine Street
- Léon 1909
- The Dory
- Opties and Dinghies
- Blue Han
- Peeko's
- King Andrew Cheese
- Mashomack Preserve
- Sylvester Manor
- SPRMRKT
- Purethread
- Pure Soul Boutique
- Finley's Fiction
- Il Laboratorio del Gelato
- Dante
Locations
- Shelter Island
- Hamptons
- North Fork
- Crescent Beach
- Shelter Heights
- Greenport
- Montauk
- New York City