ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Sarah McNally on Bestsellers, Memoirs, and 22 Years of McNally Jackson

other · 2026-07-29

Sarah McNally, founder of New York's McNally Jackson bookstores, discusses the evolution of bestsellers, her reading habits, and the philosophy behind her indie empire. In an interview with CULTURED, she reflects on 22 years since opening the first store on Prince Street, now encompassing multiple bookstores, Goods for the Study, and McNally Editions. McNally, daughter of Canadian booksellers behind McNally Robinson, notes that bestselling novels have shifted from naturalistic to more varied forms, while raw memoirs remain consistently popular. She credits her mother's store in Winnipeg for exposing her to philosophy and political theory, inspiring McNally Jackson's focus on international literature. She recommends Tove Jansson's 'The Summer Book' as a top staff pick and trusts Michael Cunningham for recommendations, though she admits she trusts no one completely. McNally cites Georges Simenon's Inspector Maigret mysteries as comfort reads, having read about 60, and admits to twice abandoning Thomas Mann's 'The Magic Mountain'. Her required reading for solitary confinement includes Javier Marías's 'Your Face Tomorrow' trilogy, Vasily Grossman's 'Life and Fate', Roberto Bolaño's '2666', Virginia Woolf's 'To the Lighthouse', and David Foster Wallace's 'The Pale King'.

Key facts

  • McNally Jackson was founded 22 years ago by Sarah McNally.
  • The first store opened on Prince Street in New York.
  • McNally is the daughter of booksellers behind Canada's McNally Robinson.
  • She worked as an editor at Basic Books before opening McNally Jackson.
  • McNally Jackson now includes multiple bookstores, Goods for the Study, and McNally Editions.
  • McNally notes that bestselling novels have shifted from naturalistic to more varied forms.
  • She recommends Tove Jansson's 'The Summer Book' as a top staff pick.
  • She trusts Michael Cunningham for book recommendations.
  • She has read about 60 Inspector Maigret mysteries by Georges Simenon.
  • She twice abandoned Thomas Mann's 'The Magic Mountain'.
  • Her solitary confinement reading list includes works by Javier Marías, Vasily Grossman, Roberto Bolaño, Virginia Woolf, and David Foster Wallace.

Entities

Artists

  • Sarah McNally
  • David Byrne
  • Claire Danes
  • Kaia Gerber
  • Lily-Rose Depp
  • Michael Cunningham
  • Tove Jansson
  • Georges Simenon
  • Thomas Mann
  • Javier Marías
  • Vasily Grossman
  • Roberto Bolaño
  • Virginia Woolf
  • David Foster Wallace

Institutions

  • McNally Jackson
  • Goods for the Study
  • McNally Editions
  • McNally Robinson
  • Basic Books
  • CULTURED
  • New York

Locations

  • New York
  • Winnipeg
  • Canada
  • Prince Street

Sources