ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Roberto Ago's Critique of Italian Art's Stalled Historiography

opinion-review · 2026-04-27

Roberto Ago, a visual critic and philosopher, publishes a three-part essay on Artribune diagnosing the failure to historicize Italian contemporary art from the 2000s and 2010s. He argues that no consensus exists on the value of artists from these decades, unlike earlier movements such as Arte Povera or Transavanguardia. Ago identifies a 'limbo of notoriety' where artists like Icaro, Nannucci, and Garutti remain unrecognized internationally, while critics and curators evade responsibility. He cites the anonymous critic Luca Rossi as a symbolic figure of this crisis, noting Rossi's 2009 emergence as a public castigator. Ago calls for a new critical approach to select and promote artists, referencing Germano Celant and Achille Bonito Oliva as models of solitary initiative. The essay includes a list of over 30 Italian artists and critiques the lack of institutional support, the proliferation of mediocre talent, and the failure of the art system to distinguish quality. Ago's text is part of a series titled 'Lezioni di critica' and appears in the context of Artribune's newsletters and social media channels.

Key facts

  • Roberto Ago wrote a three-part essay on Italian contemporary art criticism.
  • The essay focuses on art produced in Italy during the 2000s and 2010s.
  • Ago argues that no consensus exists on the value of artists from these decades.
  • He cites Germano Celant and Achille Bonito Oliva as models of critical initiative.
  • The anonymous critic Luca Rossi is presented as a symbolic figure of the crisis.
  • Ago lists over 30 Italian artists who remain in a 'limbo of notoriety'.
  • The essay criticizes the lack of institutional support and critical selection.
  • The text was published on Artribune in July 2018.

Entities

Artists

  • Roberto Ago
  • Germano Celant
  • Achille Bonito Oliva
  • Maurizio Cattelan
  • Vanessa Beecroft
  • Rudolf Stingel
  • Francesco Vezzoli
  • Giuseppe Penone
  • Giulio Paolini
  • Michelangelo Pistoletto
  • Mimmo Paladino
  • Gianfranco Baruchello
  • Icaro
  • Maurizio Nannucci
  • Alberto Garutti
  • Pirri
  • Moro
  • Airò
  • Esposito
  • Bartolini
  • Arienti
  • Pietroiusti
  • Vitone
  • Pancrazzi
  • Cecchini
  • Senatore
  • Manzelli
  • Migliora
  • Berti
  • Benassi
  • Mangano
  • Maloberti
  • Masbedo
  • vedovamazzei
  • Toderi
  • Lambri
  • Gioli
  • Cresci
  • Luca Rossi
  • Francesco Bonami
  • Angela Vettese
  • Simonetta Lux
  • Carla Subrizi
  • Rebecca Moccia
  • Lia Cecchin
  • Alek O.
  • Anne Libby
  • Paola Pivi
  • Michele Dantini
  • Fabio Cavallucci
  • Massimo De Carlo
  • Giò Marconi
  • Adriano Altamira

Institutions

  • Artribune
  • Accademia di Belle Arti di Brera
  • Università degli Studi di Milano
  • Sapienza Università di Roma
  • Controversie
  • Forum di Prato
  • Italian Council
  • Espresso
  • Exit
  • La Zona
  • Soft Cell
  • Terrazza
  • Ennesima
  • That's IT
  • Fuori
  • Quadriennale di Roma

Locations

  • Italy
  • Rome
  • Milan
  • Prato
  • Roma
  • Milano

Sources