ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Robert Indiana Estate Settlement Advances Museum Plans Amid Ongoing Legal Complexities

artist · 2026-04-20

A resolution has been achieved in the disputed legal proceedings concerning Robert Indiana's legacy, enabling the long-delayed transformation of his home on Vinalhaven Island into a museum. The Morgan Art Foundation, which holds the LOVE trademark and represented Indiana, accused his assistant Jamie Thomas of misappropriating $1 million and 100 pieces of art while permitting the artist to live in poor conditions. Thomas defended himself as a devoted caregiver safeguarding Indiana's health. Although the Morgan and publisher Michael McKenzie are still at odds, McKenzie has shown willingness to settle. Meanwhile, the Maine attorney general's office alleges the estate has excessively compensated four law firms, seeking $3.7 million, and around $400,000 from personal representative Jamie Brannan, who refutes the claims. Indiana's renowned LOVE design first appeared as a 1965 Christmas card for the Museum of Modern Art in New York, intended as a commentary on the Vietnam War. The artist did not copyright the piece, resulting in numerous unauthorized reproductions that provided him minimal financial gain despite its international acclaim. While the specifics of the settlement are not disclosed, it marks a step towards resolving the intricate litigation following Indiana's passing in 2018.

Key facts

  • Robert Indiana died in 2018
  • The LOVE design was created in 1965
  • The Morgan Art Foundation owns the LOVE trademark
  • Jamie Thomas was accused of stealing $1 million and 100 artworks
  • The Maine attorney general seeks $3.7 million from four law firms
  • Indiana's Vinalhaven Island home may become a museum
  • The LOVE design was originally a Christmas card for MoMA
  • Indiana never copyrighted the LOVE design

Entities

Artists

  • Robert Indiana

Institutions

  • Morgan Art Foundation
  • Museum of Modern Art, New York
  • Maine attorney general's office

Locations

  • Vinalhaven Island
  • Rockland
  • Maine
  • New York

Sources