ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Rebecca Bedell's 'Moved to Tears' Defends Sentimentalism in American Art

publication · 2026-04-27

Rebecca Bedell's book 'Moved to Tears: The Overthrow of the Sentimental in American Art' challenges the art world's aversion to sentimentalism. Rather than defending empathy per se, Bedell argues for the instrumental value of sentiment, citing artists like Henry Ossawa Tanner, who used sentiment to advance abolitionism and anti-Semitism opposition. The book also discusses John Singer Sargent and Mary Cassatt to counter the notion that sentimental artists are mere illustrators. Bedell traces the roots of American sentimentalism to the 19th century and notes its pervasive influence on Western communication, especially in politics, exemplified by the emotional rhetoric surrounding the Capitol Hill assault. The book is published by Princeton University Press.

Key facts

  • Rebecca Bedell is the author of 'Moved to Tears'.
  • The book argues for the instrumental role of sentimentalism in art.
  • Henry Ossawa Tanner used sentiment to support abolitionism and oppose anti-Semitism.
  • John Singer Sargent and Mary Cassatt are discussed as counterexamples to the dismissal of sentimental artists.
  • The book traces American sentimentalism back to the 19th century.
  • Sentimentalism has pervaded Western communication, especially in politics.
  • The Capitol Hill assault is cited as a recent example of emotional manipulation.
  • Published by Princeton University Press in 2018, 232 pages, $44.49.

Entities

Artists

  • John Trumbull
  • Charles Wilson Peale
  • Rebecca Bedell
  • Henry Ossawa Tanner
  • John Singer Sargent
  • Mary Cassatt
  • Thomas Hovenden

Institutions

  • Princeton University Press
  • Artribune
  • Philadelphia Museum of Art

Locations

  • United States
  • Japan
  • Washington D.C.

Sources