Peter Zumthor's LACMA Extension: A Critical Review

A scathing review of Peter Zumthor's new building for the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA) criticizes its execution, materiality, and design. The concrete work is described as poorly executed, with visible flaws that are then painted over, betraying the material's integrity. Accessibility is problematic: the main entrance requires climbing about 60 steps, and the elevator does not lead to a clear lobby. Proportions are awkward, too high and uncomfortable in relation to the body and artworks. The lighting, typically a strength in Zumthor's architecture, fails: a curtain meant to filter light does not control the harsh western sun, compromising visibility. The free-flowing layout results in disorder, mixing artworks without creating new readings. The building already feels outdated, not aged with dignity but out of time from the start. The review compares the project to a desperate long-shot attempt, noting that Zumthor's expression at the inauguration seemed distant and sad rather than proud.