Óscar Tenreiro Degwitz critiques a book on Wittgenstein as architect
Óscar Tenreiro Degwitz, in a blog post on veredes.es, critiques the book "Wittgenstein, arquitecto" (Galaxia Gutenberg, Barcelona 2020) by Bernardí Roig, Fernando Castro Flórez, and Agustín Fernández Mallo. He argues that the book misrepresents Ludwig Wittgenstein's philosophical legacy by attempting to connect his architectural work—specifically the Wittgenstein House (Kundmanngasse, Vienna, completed December 1928) and a cabin near Skjolden, Norway (completed early 1914)—to his philosophy in a way that contradicts Wittgenstein's own views. Tenreiro Degwitz accuses the authors of using tautologies and art-criticism jargon, particularly in Castro Flórez's main essay (30 pages with 166 citations), and of trivializing Wittgenstein through four performances: a barefoot philosopher in a nightgown carrying a light through the Wittgenstein House, climbing a mossy rock face near Skjolden, manipulating a model of the house, and transcribing Ravel's Piano Concerto for the Left Hand for electric guitar. He suggests the book is a commercial venture aimed at the art market. The post includes references to Tenreiro Degwitz's own 1995 essay "Sobre la naturaleza de la Crítica" and his visit to the Wittgenstein House in May 2011. The book was a gift from his former student Antonio Ochoa Piccardo.
Key facts
- Óscar Tenreiro Degwitz critiques the book 'Wittgenstein, arquitecto' (Galaxia Gutenberg, Barcelona 2020).
- The book is by Bernardí Roig, Fernando Castro Flórez, and Agustín Fernández Mallo.
- Tenreiro Degwitz argues the book misrepresents Ludwig Wittgenstein's philosophy.
- Wittgenstein built a house for his sister Gretl (Margaret) at Kundmanngasse, Vienna, completed December 1928.
- Wittgenstein built a cabin near Skjolden, Norway, completed early 1914.
- The book includes four performances: a barefoot philosopher in a nightgown with a light in the Wittgenstein House, climbing a rock face near Skjolden, manipulating a model, and transcribing Ravel's concerto for electric guitar.
- Castro Flórez's main essay has 30 pages and 166 citations.
- Tenreiro Degwitz visited the Wittgenstein House in May 2011.
- The book was a gift from Antonio Ochoa Piccardo.
- Tenreiro Degwitz wrote 'Sobre la naturaleza de la Crítica' in 1995.
Entities
Artists
- Óscar Tenreiro Degwitz
- Bernardí Roig
- Fernando Castro Flórez
- Agustín Fernández Mallo
- Ludwig Wittgenstein
- Maurice Ravel
- Antonio Ochoa Piccardo
Institutions
- Galaxia Gutenberg
- veredes.es
Locations
- Vienna
- Austria
- Kundmanngasse
- Skjolden
- Norway
- Sognefjord
- Madrid
- Spain
- Barcelona
Sources
- Veredes —