New Book Claims Leonardo da Vinci Biography Needs Rewriting
A new book by economist Riccardo Magnani, "Milanese d'adozione. La vera storia di Leonardo da Vinci a Milano," argues that Leonardo da Vinci arrived in Milan earlier than the widely accepted date of 1482. Magnani claims to have discovered a document in the Biblioteca Nazionale Centrale di Firenze, written by Benedetto Dei, that lists a "Leonardo pittore" among Florentines in Milan as early as 1480. However, critics point out that the document was already known to scholars and that its interpretation does not support a revision of Leonardo's biography. The article, published on Artribune, questions the need to rewrite history based on this evidence, citing the principle of Occam's razor and noting that the letter Leonardo sent to Ludovico il Moro in 1482, offering his services as an engineer, musician, sculptor, and painter, would have been unnecessary if he were already in Milan.
Key facts
- Riccardo Magnani published 'Milanese d'adozione. La vera storia di Leonardo da Vinci a Milano'
- The book claims Leonardo da Vinci arrived in Milan before 1482, possibly before 1480
- The claim is based on a document by Benedetto Dei found in the Biblioteca Nazionale Centrale di Firenze
- The document lists a 'Leonardo pittore' among Florentines in Milan in 1480
- Mainstream scholarship holds that Leonardo moved to Milan in 1482 after writing to Ludovico il Moro
- The document was already known to academics, including scholars Böninger and Versiero
- The article argues that the evidence does not warrant rewriting Leonardo's biography
- The principle of Occam's razor is invoked to favor the simpler explanation
Entities
Artists
- Leonardo da Vinci
- Benedetto Dei
Institutions
- Biblioteca Nazionale Centrale di Firenze
- Artribune
Locations
- Milan
- Italy
- Florence