ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Martha Mayer Erlebacher's exhibition at Forum Gallery receives critical review

opinion-review · 2026-04-22

Martha Mayer Erlebacher's exhibition at Forum Gallery in New York features narrative paintings that struggle with literalism and misplaced ambition, according to a critical review. The show includes works like Three Cats at Dusk, priced at $35,000, depicting three air-brushed women in a landscape reminiscent of Odd Nerdrum's style. Another piece, The Tarantula Nebula, shows a naked couple in missionary position under cosmic explosions, while Fusion II presents similar galactic themes. Erlebacher's Adam and Eve (The Return) depicts biblical figures with a literal approach that drains the myth of life, presenting Eden as a historical location. Her still lifes demonstrate stronger technical skill than her narrative compositions, which often feature implausible, listless female figures in dramatic landscapes. The review compares her multi-figure works to Playboy's aesthetic and references influences from Elihu Vedder and Odd Nerdrum. Press release language describing the work as exploring "lust, hunger, greed, heat, cold, beauty, horror" contrasts with the critic's assessment that Erlebacher lacks understanding of the stories she attempts to portray. The exhibition includes classical drapery, ruddy rose skies, and compositions that prioritize formal needs over narrative coherence.

Key facts

  • Martha Mayer Erlebacher exhibited at Forum Gallery in New York
  • Three Cats at Dusk is priced at $35,000
  • The exhibition includes works like The Tarantula Nebula and Fusion II
  • Adam and Eve (The Return) depicts biblical figures literally
  • Erlebacher's still lifes are more successful than narrative works
  • The review references influences from Elihu Vedder and Odd Nerdrum
  • Press release describes themes of "lust, hunger, greed, heat, cold, beauty, horror"
  • The critic finds narrative paintings suffer from literalism and misplaced ambition

Entities

Artists

  • Martha Mayer Erlebacher
  • Elihu Vedder
  • Odd Nerdrum

Institutions

  • Forum Gallery
  • artcritical

Locations

  • New York
  • United States

Sources