ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Luigi Prestinenza Puglisi Rebuts Vittorio Sgarbi on Palazzo dei Diamanti Extension

opinion-review · 2026-05-04

Architecture critic Luigi Prestinenza Puglisi has defended the Labics-designed extension of Palazzo dei Diamanti in Ferrara against Vittorio Sgarbi's objections. Puglisi contends that the development, aimed at revitalizing a deteriorated rear section, enhances the monument's utility by replacing an unsafe plastic-covered walkway. He criticizes Sgarbi for obstructing a collaborative effort that led to a public design competition, thereby squandering time and taxpayer money. Sgarbi had previously enumerated a host of cultural figures—including Andrea and Vittorio Emiliani, Arturo Carlo Quintavalle, and Mario Botta—who oppose the extension, claiming it jeopardizes the monument's integrity. Puglisi refutes these claims, asserting that the new addition is separate from the palace and addresses existing decay, underscoring the clash between preservationists and modernization supporters in Italy's architectural landscape.

Key facts

  • Luigi Prestinenza Puglisi rebuts Vittorio Sgarbi's opposition to the Labics extension of Palazzo dei Diamanti.
  • The project is for a degraded rear area and does not compromise the Renaissance monument.
  • Puglisi says the extension replaces a precarious plastic-covered walkway.
  • Sgarbi blocked the project after a public design competition, wasting time and public funds.
  • Sgarbi listed 20+ cultural figures opposing the extension, including Mario Botta and Philippe Daverio.
  • Puglisi argues the new body is detached from the palace and helps it function.
  • The controversy involves preservation vs. modernization of Italian architectural heritage.
  • The article is published on Artribune.

Entities

Artists

  • Vittorio Sgarbi
  • Luigi Prestinenza Puglisi
  • Andrea Emiliani
  • Vittorio Emiliani
  • Arturo Carlo Quintavalle
  • Eugenio Riccomini
  • Christophe Frommel
  • Sabine Frommel
  • Giuseppe Cristinelli
  • Mario Botta
  • Philippe Daverio
  • Mario Bellini
  • Luigi Malnati
  • Andrea Carandini
  • Elio Garzillo
  • Raniero Gnoli
  • Antonio Natali
  • Nicola Spinosa
  • Magris
  • Citati
  • Moni Ovadia
  • Tahar Ben Jelloun
  • Marc Fumaroli
  • Pupi Avati

Institutions

  • Labics
  • Artribune
  • Associazione Italiana di Architettura e Critica
  • Compasses
  • presS/Tletter

Locations

  • Ferrara
  • Italy
  • Palazzo dei Diamanti
  • Castel del Monte
  • Palazzo Farnese

Sources