J.D. Vance's 'I watched the stories' remark reveals a postmodern political epistemology
In a viral Oval Office video, U.S. Vice President J.D. Vance, when asked by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky if he had ever visited Ukraine to see the problems firsthand, replied that he had 'watched and seen the stories'—referring to Instagram Stories. Art historian Christian Caliandro analyzes this moment as a symptom of a postmodern rejection of objective truth, where subjects prefer simplified, self-confirming narratives over verifiable intelligence. The exchange, occurring just before a heated argument, encapsulates a clash between direct experience and mediated representation. Caliandro argues that this preference for easy, falsifiable sources over powerful truth-seeking tools is the antithesis of intelligence. The article, published on Artribune, uses the incident to reflect on contemporary culture's relationship with reality and fiction, drawing parallels to Italo Calvino's concept of the 'sea of non-objectivity.'
Key facts
- Viral video shows Trump, Vance, and media bullying Zelensky in the Oval Office.
- Vance replied to Zelensky's question about visiting Ukraine by saying 'I've actually watched and seen the stories.'
- The phrase 'stories' refers to Instagram Stories.
- Christian Caliandro is the author of the analysis.
- Caliandro teaches contemporary art history at the Accademia di Belle Arti di Firenze.
- Caliandro is a member of the scientific committee of Symbola Foundation.
- The article was published on Artribune.
- Caliandro invokes Italo Calvino's 'sea of non-objectivity' to describe the rejection of objective truth.
Entities
Artists
- Christian Caliandro
Institutions
- Accademia di Belle Arti di Firenze
- Symbola Fondazione per le Qualità italiane
- Artribune
Locations
- Oval Office
- White House
- United States
- Ukraine
- Firenze
- Italy