Italian Masterpieces at Sotheby's Auction: Repatriation Debates
The article discusses the recurring issue of Italian artworks sold abroad and the calls for their repatriation. It highlights that wealthy Italians rarely purchase these works for public collections, and the state often lacks funds. Notable past cases include Diego Velázquez's Donna Olimpia Maidalchini (sold for over €2.5 million in summer 2019) and a disputed Parmigianino painting of Saturn and Philyra (sold for €587,770). In January 2022, Sotheby's New York auctioned several Italian masterpieces on the 27th: a Vir Dolorum attributed to Botticelli, a portrait by Andrea del Sarto, and a reclining Magdalene possibly by Correggio, each estimated at several million dollars. Also offered was Gabriele Renzi's bronze and marble funerary monument of Anna Colonna Barberini (c. 1658), which could return to Palazzo Barberini. Meanwhile, two paintings by Salvator Rosa from the Galleria Nazionale were loaned to Matera under the '100 opere tornano a casa' initiative. Other works from the Cybo Malaspina collection, including Giuliano Bugiardini's 1520 Portrait of Leo X with Two Cardinals (with Innocenzo Cybo replacing Cardinal de' Rossi), could potentially return to the Ducal Palace in Massa, encouraging its cultural reuse.
Key facts
- Italian artworks sold abroad often prompt repatriation calls but rarely return due to lack of private or state funds.
- Diego Velázquez's Donna Olimpia Maidalchini sold for over €2.5 million in summer 2019.
- A disputed Parmigianino painting of Saturn and Philyra sold for €587,770.
- On January 27, 2022, Sotheby's New York auctioned works attributed to Botticelli, Andrea del Sarto, and possibly Correggio, each estimated at several million dollars.
- Gabriele Renzi's funerary monument of Anna Colonna Barberini (c. 1658) was also auctioned; it could return to Palazzo Barberini.
- Two Salvator Rosa paintings were loaned to Matera under the '100 opere tornano a casa' initiative by the Ministry of Culture.
- Giuliano Bugiardini's 1520 Portrait of Leo X with Two Cardinals from the Cybo Malaspina collection could return to the Ducal Palace in Massa.
- The Cybo Malaspina collection includes works transferred to Rome in the 1720s and acquired by the state from the Torlonia family in 1892.
Entities
Artists
- Diego Velázquez
- Parmigianino
- Sandro Botticelli
- Andrea del Sarto
- Correggio
- Gabriele Renzi
- Salvator Rosa
- Giuliano Bugiardini
- Raphael
- Innocenzo Cybo
- Luigi de' Rossi
- Anna Colonna Barberini
- Fabrizio Federici
Institutions
- Sotheby's
- Palazzo Barberini
- Galleria Nazionale
- Ministero della Cultura
- Palazzo Ducale di Massa
- Torlonia family
- Artribune
Locations
- New York
- United States
- Italy
- Matera
- Rome
- Massa