ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Italian art system criticized for lacking meritocracy compared to football

opinion-review · 2026-04-27

Ludovico Pratesi argues that Italy's contemporary art scene suffers from nepotism and lack of merit, contrasting it with the country's football culture. He notes that historical patrons like Lorenzo de' Medici, Pope Julius II, Scipione Borghese, and Popes Urban VIII and Alexander VII selected exceptional artists such as Michelangelo, Caravaggio, and Bernini. Today, politicians and officials prioritize personal tastes over merit, leading to mediocre artists being showcased in prestigious venues. Pratesi criticizes Italy's poor performance at the Venice Biennale, where the nation fields artists of varying quality without a strategy to win the Golden Lion. He calls for a systemic change to nurture top-tier artists, akin to football's focus on developing champions.

Key facts

  • Historical patrons like Medici, Gonzaga, Estensi, and Popes commissioned masterpieces from top artists.
  • Current Italian officials prioritize personal relationships over merit in art selection.
  • Italy has not won the Golden Lion at the Venice Biennale for decades.
  • Pratesi compares Italy's art system unfavorably to its football culture.
  • The Venice Biennale costs Italian taxpayers about a dozen million euros every two years.
  • Italian contemporary art museums often host foreign artists instead of nurturing local talent.
  • Pratesi is a curator and critic, former artistic director of Centro Arti Visive Pescheria in Pesaro.
  • The article was published on Artribune in May 2023.

Entities

Artists

  • Leonardo da Vinci
  • Michelangelo
  • Caravaggio
  • Gian Lorenzo Bernini

Institutions

  • Artribune
  • Centro Arti Visive Pescheria
  • Fondazione Guastalla
  • Università IULM di Milano
  • Venice Biennale

Locations

  • Italy
  • Venice
  • Pesaro
  • Milan
  • Rome

Sources