ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Italian Art Identity: Between Metaphysics and Progress

opinion-review · 2026-04-27

Anselm Kiefer has made a significant mark by becoming the first contemporary artist allowed to cover ancient masterpieces in the Palazzo Ducale, using black cloth to obscure Tintoretto's works. This provocative act, referred to as 'killing his masters,' reflects Kiefer's exploration of national identity and history, especially concerning Nazism. The artwork examines Italian artistic identity, drawing on Benedetto Croce’s views about how national identity is linked to history. It also highlights nine renowned Italian artists who shared local stories: Boccioni, Balla, Mario Sironi, de Chirico, Morandi, Burri, Manzoni, Fontana, and Cattelan. The piece suggests that Italian identity is shaped by both metaphysical and progressive influences, with differing views from Jean Clair and Germano Celant contributing to the discussion. Ultimately, it argues that contemporary Italian art struggles because it lacks connection to the sacred and metaphysical roots of Italian culture.

Key facts

  • Anselm Kiefer is the first contemporary artist allowed to cover ancient artworks in Palazzo Ducale.
  • Kiefer covered Tintoretto's works with black cloth.
  • Kiefer's act is described as 'killing his masters' to surpass them.
  • Benedetto Croce defined national identity as 'its history, all its history, nothing but its history.'
  • Nine Italian artists achieved global recognition: Futurism (Boccioni, Balla), Mario Sironi, Giorgio de Chirico, Giorgio Morandi, Alberto Burri, Piero Manzoni, Lucio Fontana, Arte Povera, and Maurizio Cattelan.
  • Jean Clair traced Italian identity to 'the melancholic solitude of the metaphysical mannequin.'
  • Germano Celant traced Italian identity to 'the imaginative vitality embodied by Futurism.'
  • The article claims Italian identity lies in the tension between metaphysics and progress.

Entities

Artists

  • Anselm Kiefer
  • Tintoretto
  • Jackson Pollock
  • Andy Warhol
  • Jasper Johns
  • Robert Rauschenberg
  • Jeff Koons
  • Jenny Holzer
  • David Hammons
  • Christopher Wool
  • Umberto Boccioni
  • Giacomo Balla
  • Mario Sironi
  • Giorgio de Chirico
  • Giorgio Morandi
  • Alberto Burri
  • Piero Manzoni
  • Lucio Fontana
  • Maurizio Cattelan
  • Jago
  • Igor Mitoraj
  • Achille Bonito Oliva
  • Benedetto Croce
  • Jean Clair
  • Germano Celant
  • Thomas Stearns Eliot
  • Virgil
  • Richard Wagner
  • Friedrich Nietzsche
  • Immanuel Kant

Institutions

  • Palazzo Ducale
  • Centre Pompidou
  • Museo Villa Bassi
  • MAECI
  • Fondazione CDP
  • CONAI
  • Musei Capitolini
  • Museo Nazionale Romano
  • Parco Archeologico dell'Appia
  • Spazio Taverna
  • Artribune

Locations

  • Venice
  • Italy
  • Germany
  • United States
  • Rome
  • Moscow
  • China
  • Paris
  • Abano Terme

Sources