ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Irving Sandler's 2009 book reexamines Abstract Expressionism's American identity and scholarly debates

publication · 2026-04-22

Irving Sandler's 2009 book, "Abstract Expressionism and the American Experience: A Revaluation," takes a fresh look at Abstract Expressionism during its formative years, from 1942 to 1952. Published by Hard Press Editions in partnership with the School of Visual Arts and Hudson Hills Press, this work serves as an update to his earlier piece, "The Triumph of American Painting." Sandler delves into why some artists gained recognition, linking the movement's American origins to themes found in Western films—228 of which were produced by Hollywood. He suggests classifying Barnett Newman, Mark Rothko, and Clyfford Still as Color-Field painters, which could be confusing. Additionally, he connects Jackson Pollock's style to emotional depth and international turmoil, although some critics argue his views might be outdated and narrowly focused.

Key facts

  • Irving Sandler published "Abstract Expressionism and the American Experience: A Revaluation" in 2009
  • The book focuses on Abstract Expressionism from 1942 to 1952
  • Sandler proposes calling Barnett Newman, Mark Rothko, and Clyfford Still Color-Field painters
  • 228 Westerns were produced by Hollywood during Abstract Expressionism's heyday
  • The book includes an essay attacking Serge Guilbaut's "How New York Stole the Idea of Modern Art"
  • Sandler interprets Newman's work as reflecting anarchist beliefs through pictorial openness
  • The review criticizes Sandler for not engaging sufficiently with recent scholarship
  • The book is published by Hard Press Editions and the School of Visual Arts with Hudson Hills Press

Entities

Artists

  • Irving Sandler
  • Barnett Newman
  • Mark Rothko
  • Clyfford Still
  • Jackson Pollock
  • Morris Louis
  • Kenneth Noland
  • Jules Olitski
  • Robert Morris
  • Caravaggio
  • Édouard Manet
  • Clement Greenberg
  • David Anfam
  • T.J. Clark
  • Pepe Karmel
  • Ellen Landau
  • Rosalind Krauss
  • Serge Guilbaut
  • Sean Scully
  • Hal Foster
  • Yve-Alain Bois
  • Benjamin H.D. Buchloh
  • Frank Lloyd Wright

Institutions

  • Hard Press Editions
  • School of Visual Arts
  • Hudson Hills Press
  • Hollywood
  • artcritical

Locations

  • Manhattan
  • New York
  • United States
  • Beijing
  • China
  • Rome
  • Italy
  • Paris
  • France

Sources