ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Ines Schaber's Project Examines Aby Warburg's 1895 Hopi Photographs and Ethical Viewing

artist · 2026-04-20

Ines Schaber, a German artist, launched her project Notes on Archives in 2004 to explore the intersections of photographic archives and colonial histories. Central to this endeavor is the Unnamed Series (2008–09), developed in collaboration with Stefan Pente, which addresses the contentious release of images by Aby Warburg from his 1895 encounter with the Hopi people. Although Warburg opposed their publication, these images were first made public in 1939 and subsequently reprinted in 1988, 1995, 1998, and 2018, despite objections from the Hopi. The Hopi consider these images a breach of sacred knowledge. Schaber's work, showcased at Camera Austria in 2018, features an audio component that interrogates the ethics of image circulation and includes critiques from Hopi representatives, discussing possible actions such as reframing or repatriating the images.

Key facts

  • Ines Schaber's Notes on Archives project began in 2004.
  • Aby Warburg photographed Hopi rituals in December 1895.
  • The Hopi banned photography of sacred ceremonies by the 1930s.
  • Warburg's images were first published posthumously in 1939 by the Warburg Institute.
  • The images have been republished in 1988, 1995, 1998, and 2018.
  • Schaber's Unnamed Series (2008–09) was created with Stefan Pente.
  • The Hopi Cultural Preservation Office requested a moratorium on displaying such materials in 1994.
  • A reconstructed version of Warburg's Mnemosyne Atlas is on show at the Haus der Kulturen der Welt in Berlin.

Entities

Artists

  • Ines Schaber
  • Stefan Pente
  • Goshka Macuga
  • Emo Verkerk
  • Karen Peters
  • Chris Fite-Wassilak

Institutions

  • Camera Austria
  • Warburg Institute
  • Hopi Cultural Preservation Office (HCPO)
  • Haus der Kulturen der Welt
  • Artforum
  • Frieze
  • Hyperallergic
  • Artreview.com

Locations

  • Graz
  • Austria
  • Santa Fe
  • United States
  • Berlin
  • Germany
  • London
  • United Kingdom
  • Hopiland
  • North American continent
  • American southwest

Sources