Human skulls attached to looted Asante instruments create ethical restitution dilemma for Fowler Museum
At UCLA's Fowler Museum, two musical artifacts from West Africa present a restitution dilemma because they are accompanied by human skulls. A drum and an ivory trumpet were taken by British soldiers from Kumasi, in the Asante kingdom, during the late 19th century. Although the museum intends to return these items to Ghana, ethical concerns emerge since the skulls likely belonged to adversaries of the Asante. The trumpet's skull is identified as that of a 40-year-old male who suffered a fatal head injury, while the drum’s cranium belongs to a 50-year-old female. Both instruments were auctioned in London in 1919 and 1930, donated to the Fowler in 1965, and have never been exhibited. Ongoing negotiations with Ghana's Ministry of Tourism and other parties have yet to yield a resolution.
Key facts
- Two musical instruments with human skulls attached are in the Fowler Museum's collection
- Instruments were looted by British troops from Kumasi in the late 19th century
- Skulls likely belong to enemies of the Asante kingdom
- Trumpet skull is from a 40-year-old male with fatal head wound
- Drum cranium is from a 50-year-old woman
- Instruments sold in London auctions in 1919 and 1930 to Henry Wellcome
- Donated to Fowler Museum in 1965 and never publicly displayed
- Confidential restitution discussions with Ghana ongoing for seven years
Entities
Artists
- Barnaby Phillips
- Erica Jones
- Carlee Forbes
- Kwasi Ampene
- Kodzo Gavua
- Henry Wellcome
- Otumfuo Nana Osei Tutu II
Institutions
- Fowler Museum
- University of California, Los Angeles
- Manhyia Palace Museum
- Tufts University
- Ghana Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Creative Arts
- National Focal Team on Restitution and Repatriation
- Ghana Museums and Monuments Board
- National Museum
- The Art Newspaper
Locations
- Los Angeles
- United States
- Kumasi
- Ghana
- London
- United Kingdom
- Accra
- Massachusetts