Gianluca Peluffo calls for architects to protest in squares over Ferrara competition scandal
Architect Gianluca Peluffo, in a passionate op-ed on Artribune, urges Italian architects to take to the streets to protest the cancellation of the Palazzo dei Diamanti competition in Ferrara, which he calls a 'surreal' and 'criminal' act against the profession. Peluffo argues that the affair, triggered by Vittorio Sgarbi's intervention, reveals the deep elitism and lack of democracy in Italy's architectural system. He contrasts the situation with France, where a 1977 law mandates two-phase public competitions for all public works, fostering quality and diffusion. Peluffo criticizes the Italian elite, including Renzo Piano, for not supporting competition laws, and calls for a lobby of cities to push for legislative reforms. He highlights his own generation's struggles, citing the 5+1AA's victory in the Venice Palazzo del Cinema competition (2004-05) as a rare success that was later undermined. Peluffo also notes the CNAPPC's efforts to promote an Architecture Law, but laments the lack of support from prominent figures. He concludes by calling for protests at the Ministry of Cultural Heritage and for architects to sit with mayors to shape the future of cities.
Key facts
- Palazzo dei Diamanti competition in Ferrara was cancelled
- Vittorio Sgarbi played a key role in the controversy
- Peluffo compares Sgarbi to a McGuffin in Hitchcock films
- France's 1977 law mandates two-phase public competitions for all public works
- 5+1AA won the Venice Palazzo del Cinema competition in 2004-05
- Renzo Piano did not support the Architecture Law promoted by CNAPPC
- CNAPPC is the National Council of Architects, Planners, Landscapers and Conservators
- Peluffo proposes a lobby of cities to push for urban and architectural reforms
Entities
Artists
- Gianluca Peluffo
- Vittorio Sgarbi
- Renzo Piano
- Rudy Ricciotti
- Massimiliano Fuksas
- Rafael Moneo
- Stefano Boeri
- Vittorio Gregotti
- Italo Lupi
- Mario Bellini
- Ermanno Ranzani
- Pierluigi Nicolin
- Giancarlo De Carlo
- Bruno Zevi
Institutions
- Artribune
- 5+1AA
- Labics
- Palazzo del Cinema di Venezia
- Biennale di Venezia
- IUAV
- CNAPPC
- Senato della Repubblica
- Auditorium Parco della Musica
- BNL BNP Paribas
- Università IULM
- Agenzia Spaziale Italiana
- Ministero degli Interni
- Docks di Marsiglia
- Ministero dei Beni Culturali
- Accademia di Belle Arti di Perugia
- ENA Marrakech
- Casabella
- Abitare
- Domus
- Lotus
- Spazio e Società
- L'Architettura
- Corriere della Sera
- ANCI
Locations
- Ferrara
- Italy
- France
- Venice
- Rome
- Milan
- Genoa
- Marrakech
- Morocco
- Egypt
- Sokhna
- Cornedo Vicentino
- Enna
- Perugia