ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Florida principal fired for showing Michelangelo's David to students; Florence mayor invites her to Italy

other · 2026-04-27

Hope Carasquilla, principal of the Classical School of Tallahassee in Florida, was forced to resign after showing Michelangelo's David to students during art history lessons. Three parents deemed the statue's nudity pornographic and inappropriate. The school's board president upheld the complaint, despite art history being mandatory in the curriculum. Carasquilla also showed the Creation of Adam from the Sistine Chapel. Under school policy, she should have given two weeks' notice for controversial content. Florence Mayor Dario Nardella invited Carasquilla to Florence to see the David in person and receive a city prize, calling the confusion of art with pornography "ridiculous." Cecilie Hollberg, director of the Galleria dell'Accademia where the David is housed, echoed that nudity is not pornography and invited the school community to visit. Carasquilla expressed gratitude and said she would like to return. The incident follows Nardella's recent involvement with climate activists from Ultima Generazione who protested at Palazzo Vecchio; their homes were later searched by court order.

Key facts

  • Hope Carasquilla was forced to resign as principal of the Classical School of Tallahassee after showing Michelangelo's David to students.
  • Three parents complained that the statue's nudity was pornographic and inappropriate.
  • The school board president deemed the complaints valid, despite art history being a mandatory part of the curriculum.
  • Carasquilla also showed the Creation of Adam from the Sistine Chapel ceiling.
  • School policy required two weeks' advance notice for controversial content.
  • Florence Mayor Dario Nardella invited Carasquilla to Florence to see the David and receive a city prize.
  • Cecilie Hollberg, director of the Galleria dell'Accademia, stated that nudity does not equal pornography.
  • The Galleria dell'Accademia invited the school community to visit Florence to see the David.
  • Nardella had recently confronted climate activists from Ultima Generazione who protested at Palazzo Vecchio.
  • The homes of the activists involved in the protest were later searched by court order.

Entities

Artists

  • Michelangelo Buonarroti
  • Giorgio Vasari
  • Emilio de Fabris

Institutions

  • Classical School of Tallahassee
  • Galleria dell'Accademia
  • Palazzo Vecchio
  • Ultima Generazione

Locations

  • Tallahassee
  • Florida
  • United States
  • Florence
  • Italy

Sources