ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Florence's Piazza Duomo sculpture controversy: Region Tuscany's cultural policy under fire

opinion-review · 2026-04-26

The controversy surrounding Emanuele Giannelli's sculptures in Piazza Duomo, Florence, has escalated beyond the initial negative review by Artribune. The exhibition's press office responded with insults and threats, amplifying the story. However, the real issue is the Region of Tuscany's cultural policy, led by President Eugenio Giani, who holds the culture portfolio without a dedicated assessor. Critics say Giani prioritizes folkloric events over contemporary art, with the Toscanaincontemporanea fund receiving only €400,000 annually. The region's exhibitions at Palazzo Strozzi Sacrati lack artistic direction. The sculptures were approved in record time—one month—after a free offer from the artist, raising questions about procedure. The region now considers closing the show early.

Key facts

  • Emanuele Giannelli's sculptures in Piazza Duomo, Florence, sparked controversy after a negative Artribune review.
  • The exhibition's press office responded with insults and threats, making the story viral.
  • Region of Tuscany President Eugenio Giani holds the culture portfolio; there is no assessor for culture.
  • The Toscanaincontemporanea fund provides only €400,000 annually for contemporary art.
  • The region's exhibitions at Palazzo Strozzi Sacrati lack a coherent curatorial vision.
  • The sculptures were approved in one month after a free offer from the artist.
  • The region is considering closing the exhibition early.
  • Critics say local media avoid criticizing the region due to advertising revenue.

Entities

Artists

  • Emanuele Giannelli
  • Massimiliano Tonelli

Institutions

  • Artribune
  • Region of Tuscany
  • Palazzo Strozzi Sacrati

Locations

  • Florence
  • Italy
  • Piazza Duomo
  • Tuscany

Sources