ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Fairs and Biennials as Obstacles to Art's True Potential

opinion-review · 2026-04-27

Christian Caliandro argues that contemporary art's institutional system—fairs, biennials, major exhibitions—has become a rusty, jammed machine that prevents artworks from fulfilling their real functions, reducing them to decoration or financial investment. He traces this to the system's alignment with privileged classes, where art serves the rich and adopts a rhetoric of social concern while being fundamentally conservative. Drawing on documenta15 as an example, he contends that the core issue now lies not in the artworks themselves but in the dispositifs that frame them. Caliandro contrasts this with a progressive, evolving art that deliberately ignores the system and builds alternative dimensions for art experience, bypassing established paradigms like the clear separation between artwork and space, art and reality, spectacle and audience. He also reflects on Arte Povera's legacy, noting that its linguistic revolution was eventually absorbed by the market, neutralizing its utopian aspirations. The article references Candice Breitz's critique of 'poverty pornography' at the festivalfilosofia in Modena, and Gianluigi Simonetti's observation about the centrality of marginality in literature, applying it to art criticism. Caliandro calls for an art that merges with reality and its contradictions, capable of touching people from the inside, as Jonas Mekas said.

Key facts

  • The institutional system (fairs, biennials, major exhibitions) is described as a rusty, jammed machine.
  • The system supports the interests of the privileged class, making art decorative and rhetorical.
  • Artworks often exploit the aesthetics of social marginality for profit, termed 'poverty pornography' by Candice Breitz.
  • documenta15 is cited as an example of the failure of current dispositifs.
  • Arte Povera's linguistic revolution was absorbed by the market, neutralizing its utopian goals.
  • Progressive art ignores the system and builds alternative dimensions for art experience.
  • Caliandro quotes Jonas Mekas: 'to grasp life from the inside, not from the outside'.
  • Gianluigi Simonetti's comment on the centrality of marginality in literature is applied to art criticism.
  • The article was published in September 2022 on Artribune.
  • Caliandro is an art historian and professor at Accademia di Belle Arti di Firenze.

Entities

Artists

  • Christian Caliandro
  • Candice Breitz
  • Jonas Mekas
  • Elena Bellantoni
  • Elisa Merra
  • Ivana Antonini
  • Serena Fineschi
  • Fiamma Montezemolo
  • Selenia Marabello
  • Gianluigi Simonetti

Institutions

  • Artribune
  • Accademia di Belle Arti di Firenze
  • Symbola Fondazione per le Qualità italiane
  • Premio Strega
  • Il Sole 24 Ore
  • Le parole e le cose
  • festivalfilosofia di Modena
  • documenta15
  • Cantieri Montelupo
  • Montelupo Fiorentino

Locations

  • Modena
  • Italy
  • Montelupo Fiorentino
  • Firenze

Sources