ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Eric Sutphin and Noah Dillon discuss Manet's Boating at the Met, exploring vision and art criticism

publication · 2026-04-22

At the Metropolitan Museum of Art, painter and writer Eric Sutphin engaged in a conversation with Noah Dillon about Édouard Manet's Boating (1874) for artcritical.com. Although Sutphin initially selected William-Adolphe Bouguereau's Nymphs and Satyr (1873), which was not on display, he referenced Simon Schama's 2006 documentary series The Power of Art, correcting its assertion regarding raw canvas. He highlighted Manet's unconventional Impressionist traits, connecting them to Paul Virilio's Open Sky (2008). Sutphin contrasted Manet with Bouguereau, a critic of Impressionism, and examined the painting's abstraction and pentimento. Additionally, he reviewed "The Forever Now" at MoMA and has written for Art in America and The Brooklyn Rail. He resides in New York City and is an alumnus of Rutgers University and The School of Visual Arts.

Key facts

  • Eric Sutphin and Noah Dillon discussed Édouard Manet's Boating (1874) at the Metropolitan Museum of Art
  • The conversation was part of a new series on artcritical.com launched in 2015
  • Sutphin originally chose William-Adolphe Bouguereau's Nymphs and Satyr (1873), but it was not on view
  • Simon Schama's The Power of Art (2006) inaccurately claimed part of the sail was raw canvas
  • Sutphin linked the painting's horizonless composition to ideas from Paul Virilio's Open Sky (2008)
  • He contrasted Manet with Bouguereau, noting both are now in the same museum
  • A pentimento in the painting shows a rope was moved, compared to Marcel Duchamp's work
  • Sutphin is writing a biography of post-war American painter Rosemarie Beck (1923-2003)

Entities

Artists

  • Eric Sutphin
  • Noah Dillon
  • Édouard Manet
  • William-Adolphe Bouguereau
  • Simon Schama
  • Paul Virilio
  • Marcel Duchamp
  • Rosemarie Beck
  • Detlef Aderhold
  • Degas

Institutions

  • Metropolitan Museum of Art
  • artcritical.com
  • MoMA
  • Art in America
  • Painting is Dead
  • On Verge
  • American Artist Magazine
  • The Brooklyn Rail
  • Delaware College of Art and Design
  • The School of Visual Arts
  • National Arts Club
  • Rutgers University: Mason Gross School of the Arts

Locations

  • New York City
  • United States

Sources