ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Debate on Nihilism in Contemporary French Novels

opinion-review · 2026-04-23

In response to Philippe Forest's text 'Le roman, le rien' published in art press issue 244, Guy Scarpetta continues the debate on nihilism in the contemporary novel. He argues that the new orthodoxy is one of absolute anti-modernity, systematically hating the new, and taking a more radical position than merely revisiting aesthetic values discarded by postmodernity. This orthodoxy forbids, in the name of art, any critical spirit toward the theses defended in a thesis novel, a disguised essay. This postulate of the writer's absolute innocence, placed beyond discussion, flagrantly benefits writers like Michel Houellebecq.

Key facts

  • Philippe Forest wrote 'Le roman, le rien' in art press issue 244.
  • Guy Scarpetta responds to Forest's text.
  • Scarpetta identifies a new doxa of absolute anti-modernity.
  • This doxa systematically hates the new.
  • It is more radical than revisiting postmodernity's discarded values.
  • The doxa forbids critical spirit toward thesis novels.
  • Thesis novels are disguised essays.
  • Michel Houellebecq benefits from this postulate of innocence.

Entities

Artists

  • Philippe Forest
  • Guy Scarpetta
  • Michel Houellebecq

Institutions

  • art press

Sources