Creative Scotland crisis: Dixon resigns after artist revolt
Creative Scotland, the national arts funding body, faced a crisis in 2012 after shifting to lottery-based project funding, sparking protests from artists and leading to the resignation of executive director Andrew Dixon on 4 December. The controversy began in spring 2012 when Creative Scotland withdrew its flexible funding scheme, forcing 49 arts organizations to reapply every six months. Critics, including playwrights, poets, and Turner Prize winners, condemned the body's language of 'delivering services' and 'outcomes,' and its funding of a BBC2 cookery show. A letter published in The Herald on 9 October, signed by 100 leading figures, accused Creative Scotland of 'ill-conceived decision-making' and lack of empathy. The board later pledged reforms, including multi-year funding. The crisis reflected a broader shift under the UK Coalition and SNP governments to replace direct arts funding with lottery money, a policy that disproportionately affects low-income lottery buyers. A Scottish Artist Union survey found three-quarters of visual artists earn under £5,000 a year.
Key facts
- Creative Scotland withdrew flexible funding in spring 2012, affecting 49 organizations.
- Andrew Dixon resigned on 4 December 2012.
- Venu Dhupa resigned on 20 December 2012.
- A letter of protest on 9 October 2012 was signed by 100 leading arts figures.
- Creative Scotland's budget shifted from government grants to lottery funds from 2013.
- Lottery funds could only be used for one-off projects.
- Three-quarters of Scottish visual artists earn under £5,000 a year.
- The controversy was part of wider opposition to UK public spending cuts.
Entities
Artists
- Sarah Lowndes
- Andrew Dixon
- Jack McConnell
- Alex Salmond
- Ian Bell
- Sandy Crombie
- Venu Dhupa
- Joyce McMillan
- Peter Arnott
- Ian Brown
- David Greig
- David Harrower
- Zinnie Harris
- Linda McLean
- Douglas Maxwell
- Don Paterson
- Liz Lochhead
- Peter Maxwell Davies
- James Kelman
- AL Kennedy
- Andrew O'Hagan
- Ian Rankin
- Alasdair Gray
- Martin Boyce
- Douglas Gordon
- Richard Wright
- George Osborne
- Antony Gormley
- Norman Foster
Institutions
- Creative Scotland
- Scottish Screen
- Scottish Arts Council
- National Lottery
- BBC2
- STV Productions
- The Herald
- The Scotsman
- Scottish Artist Union
- BALTIC Centre for Contemporary Art
- Sage Gateshead
- Standard Life
- NewcastleGateshead Initiative
- CCA
- NVA
- Transmission Gallery
- Common Guild
- Vanishing Point
- Grid Iron
Locations
- Scotland
- United Kingdom
- Edinburgh
- Glasgow
- NewcastleGateshead
- England
Sources
- Afterall —