Consumer Reports Ranks Best Air Fryer Toaster Ovens of 2026

Consumer Reports tested four air fryer toaster ovens to identify the top performers for toasting, baking, reheating, and ease of use. The lineup includes the DeLonghi EO141164M ($250), GE G9OAAASSPSS ($148), Ninja DCT401 ($330), and Ninja DCT821 ($365). The Ninja DCT401 scored highest overall, with excellent ratings for ease of use and toast color range, and very good marks for baking, full batch toasting, one-slice toasting, and toasting speed. The GE model was rated excellent for ease of use, full batch toasting, toast color range, and one-slice toasting, with very good baking and good toasting speed and reheating. The Ninja DCT821, featuring two independent oven cavities, was rated behind the DCT401 and GE, with no detailed test results published. The DeLonghi model was rated lowest overall, though it offers nine presets and a 14-liter capacity. Consumer Reports noted that the Ninja DCT821 can sync cavities to finish dishes simultaneously, but some owners reported condensation and uneven browning. The GE model was praised for its lack of notable flaws and its dial and pushbutton controls. The DeLonghi's Heat Lock System claims to reduce heat loss by 30% and preheat 60% faster than a full-size oven. The testing aimed to help shoppers find a multitasking appliance that fits their kitchen.