ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Christian Nationalism's Intellectual Roots and Its Challenge to American Democracy

opinion-review · 2026-07-31

J. Basil Dannebohm, a writer and former state legislator, critiques the influence of Christian Nationalism in American Christianity, tracing its intellectual origins to Rousas John 'R.J.' Rushdoony, an Armenian American Calvinist who believed democracy was heresy and advocated for replacing U.S. law with biblical law. Rushdoony, who died in 2001, supported stoning homosexuals, silencing women, dismantling public schools, and held racist views, including opposition to interracial marriage and defense of slavery. Dannebohm cites Andrew L. Seidel's book 'The Founding Myth: Why Christian Nationalism Is Un-American,' which argues that Donald Trump's authoritarian tendencies appealed to evangelicals' ingrained reverence for extreme authority, as exemplified by Ann Coulter calling Trump her 'Emperor God.' The article also references Brian Zahnd's 'Postcards from Babylon' and Walter Brueggemann's 'A Way other than Our Own,' both advocating for a countercultural Christianity detached from empire and nationalism. Dannebohm concludes that much of American Christianity is failing the litmus test of love, as highlighted by the hymn 'They'll Know We Are Christians by Our Love.' The piece underscores the ongoing debate over the separation of church and state, referencing Thomas Jefferson's warning against government-supported religion.

Key facts

  • R.J. Rushdoony believed democracy was heresy and sought to replace U.S. law with biblical law.
  • Rushdoony supported stoning homosexuals, silencing women, and dismantling public schools.
  • Rushdoony was a divorced, racist, Holocaust denier who opposed interracial marriage and called slavery 'benevolent.'
  • Andrew L. Seidel's book 'The Founding Myth' argues Trump's authoritarianism appealed to evangelicals.
  • Ann Coulter called Trump her 'Emperor God.'
  • Brian Zahnd's 'Postcards from Babylon' calls for making Christianity countercultural again.
  • Walter Brueggemann's 'A Way other than Our Own' says the church crisis is about giving up on baptismal faith for a generic U.S. identity.
  • Thomas Jefferson warned that government-supported religion undermines civil rights.

Entities

Artists

  • J. Basil Dannebohm
  • Rousas John Rushdoony
  • Andrew L. Seidel
  • Brian Zahnd
  • Walter Brueggemann
  • Thomas Jefferson
  • Ann Coulter
  • Donald Trump

Locations

  • Kansas
  • Washington DC
  • United States

Sources