ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Christian Caliandro on Art's Comfort Zone and the Loss of Authenticity

opinion-review · 2026-04-27

In a critical essay on Artribune, art historian Christian Caliandro argues that contemporary art has become a 'comfort zone' where works function as advertisements disguised as art, echoing David Foster Wallace's 1997 observation. Caliandro contends that most art today serves the interests of its financiers rather than viewers, undermining authenticity. He connects this to Carla Lonzi's 1970s reflections on authenticity in art, artist, and viewer relationships. Caliandro suggests that only a 'cure'—an affective, reciprocal relationship between artwork and viewer—can disrupt the current power-imbalanced system. He cites Josif Brodskij's 1987 Nobel lecture on the occasional nature of presence in space, lamenting that art has become 'a space accustomed to its content.' The essay is part of a series on 'sfrangiata' (frayed) art and its need for truth.

Key facts

  • David Foster Wallace's 1997 essay 'A Supposedly Fun Thing I'll Never Do Again' is cited.
  • Carla Lonzi's 1970s reflections on authenticity are referenced.
  • Josif Brodskij's Nobel lecture from December 10, 1987 is quoted.
  • Christian Caliandro is an art historian and professor at Accademia di Belle Arti di Firenze.
  • The essay is part of a series on 'arte sfrangiata' (frayed art).
  • Caliandro is a member of the scientific committee of Symbola Foundation.
  • The essay was published on Artribune in June 2022.
  • Caliandro argues that most contemporary art functions as advertising.

Entities

Artists

  • David Foster Wallace
  • Carla Lonzi
  • Josif Brodskij
  • Christian Caliandro

Institutions

  • Artribune
  • Accademia di Belle Arti di Firenze
  • Symbola Fondazione per le Qualità italiane
  • Adelphi
  • Castelvecchi Editore

Locations

  • Firenze
  • Italy
  • Milano

Sources