Banksy's company loses urgent trademark case against Milan exhibition
Pest Control Office Ltd, the company managing Banksy's rights, filed an urgent lawsuit against 24 Ore Cultura S.r.l., organizer of the exhibition "The art of Banksy. A visual protest" at the Mudec in Milan. The claimant argued unauthorized use of the name "Banksy" and trademarked images (Girl with Balloon, Flower Thrower) in the exhibition title and promotional material. On January 15, 2019, the Milan Tribunal ruled that using the artist's name and images for exhibition promotion was lawful, as it is standard practice for solo shows. However, it ordered the museum to stop selling merchandise bearing the trademarks, as such use was not descriptive. The ruling addresses copyright issues in street art, noting that street art's public and ephemeral nature may imply a waiver of authorial rights. The decision contrasts with other cases, such as the Italian KayOne case (where a court protected street artist rights for works on canvas) and the US MSK vs. Cavalli case. Banksy's reliance on trademark rather than copyright is seen as a strategy to avoid revealing his identity.
Key facts
- Pest Control Office Ltd sued 24 Ore Cultura S.r.l. over the exhibition 'The art of Banksy. A visual protest' at Mudec Milan.
- The lawsuit claimed unauthorized use of the name 'Banksy' and trademarked images (Girl with Balloon, Flower Thrower).
- Milan Tribunal ruled on January 15, 2019, that using the artist's name and images for exhibition promotion was lawful.
- The court ordered the museum to stop selling merchandise bearing Banksy's trademarks.
- The ruling addresses copyright issues in street art, suggesting public display may imply waiver of authorial rights.
- The case is one of the first Italian rulings on street art copyright.
- Previous Italian case: KayOne vs. Nicola Leonetti (works on canvas) recognized artist rights.
- US precedent: MSK crew vs. Cavalli over reproduction of murals in clothing.
Entities
Artists
- Banksy
- Marco Mantovani (KayOne)
- Nicola Leonetti
- Jason "Revok" Williams
- Victor "Reyes" Chapa
- Jeoffrey "Steel"
Institutions
- Pest Control Office Ltd
- 24 Ore Cultura S.r.l.
- Mudec (Museo delle Culture)
- Tribunale di Milano
- Cavalli
- MSK
- Negri-Clementi Studio Legale Associato
- Artribune
Locations
- Milan
- Italy
- United States