Architecture criticism in the digital age: everyone can be a critic
In his recent article for the 'Conversazioni di Architettura' series on Artribune, Luigi Prestinenza Puglisi argues that architectural criticism is no longer just for experts. He points out that the rise of the internet and social media has democratized this space. Puglisi critiques the historical control held by architecture magazines like Casabella and Domus, whose prominent leaders—like Marcello Piacentini and Gio Ponti—wielded too much power. He believes critics should connect people rather than simply judge. He warns against the dangers of 'operative criticism,' as exemplified by Bruno Zevi, and notes the rise of PR firms promoting superficial ideas like 'vertical forest.' Puglisi suggests that online platforms are reshaping criticism, urging traditional print to adapt or risk fading away.
Key facts
- Luigi Prestinenza Puglisi is the author of the essay.
- The essay is the ninth in the 'Conversazioni di Architettura' series.
- Puglisi argues that criticism is an innate human faculty.
- He cites the Enlightenment and Kant's idea of emerging from minority.
- He references Umberto Eco's complaint about 'cretins' having platforms.
- Historical gatekeepers include directors of Casabella and Domus.
- Puglisi warns against 'operative criticism' as theorized by Bruno Zevi.
- He notes the rise of paid communication as a threat to genuine critique.
- The essay discusses the migration of criticism to social media.
- Puglisi predicts print criticism will either adapt or die.
Entities
Artists
- Luigi Prestinenza Puglisi
- Zaha Hadid
- Bruno Zevi
- Immanuel Kant
- Aristotle
- Umberto Eco
- Frank Lloyd Wright
- Monaco
- Luccichenti
- Lina Bo Bardi
- Luigi Pellegrin
- Leonardo Ricci
- Aldo Loris Rossi
- Vittorio Giorgini
- Sergio Musmeci
- Leonardo Savioli
- Vittoriano Viganò
- Marcello Piacentini
- Ernesto Nathan Rogers
- Gio Ponti
- Vittorio Gregotti
- Francesco Dal Co
- Stefano Boeri
- Marco Casamonti
- Achille Bonito Oliva
- Michelangelo
- Borromini
- Brunelleschi
- Benedetto Croce
- Viktor Sklovskij
- Renzo Piano
- Susan Sontag
Institutions
- Artribune
- Casabella
- Domus
- MoMA
- Biennale di Venezia
- Amazon
Locations
- Italy
- Catania
- Venice
- New York