Ansel Adams Trust Condemns AI-Colourized Moonrise Print at Aipad Fair
At the Aipad Photography Show in New York in April 2025, Danziger Gallery displayed an AI-colourized version of Ansel Adams's Moonrise, Hernandez, New Mexico (1941), offered in three editions priced at $6,000, $8,000, and $10,000. The Ansel Adams Publishing Rights Trust, which manages the artist's legacy, was not consulted and issued a statement condemning the work as an exploitation of Adams's name and reputation. The trust demanded its removal, but Danziger kept it on display and allegedly used the controversy to promote a commercial venture colourizing works from other artists' estates with AI. Danziger defended the piece, claiming the image is in the public domain and that he hired a copyright lawyer to ensure legality. He described using an AI prompt as a starting point, then refining the image with Photoshop. The incident sparked widespread backlash from photographers and industry figures, including former White House photographer Pete Souza and David Kennerly, a friend of Adams and trust member, who called the colourization 'weird and disrespectful'—citing Danziger's own 2012 blog post against colourization. Aipad stated it is taking the matter seriously and has formed an ethics committee to address AI use. Artists Giuseppe Lo Schiavo and Petra Cortright offered mixed reactions, while photographer Jim Krantz, who studied with Adams, called the AI work 'a sham.' The controversy highlights tensions between copyright, moral rights, and AI-generated art.
Key facts
- Danziger Gallery displayed an AI-colourized version of Ansel Adams's Moonrise, Hernandez, New Mexico (1941) at the Aipad Photography Show in April 2025.
- The work was offered in three editions of ten: $6,000, $8,000, and $10,000.
- The Ansel Adams Publishing Rights Trust was not consulted and condemned the work as exploitation.
- Danziger kept the work on display despite the trust's request for removal.
- Danziger claimed the image is in the public domain and hired a copyright lawyer.
- Former White House photographer Pete Souza and David Kennerly criticized the colourization.
- Aipad formed an ethics committee to address AI use in art.
- Photographer Jim Krantz called the AI work 'a sham' and 'smoke and mirrors.'
Entities
Artists
- Ansel Adams
- Giuseppe Lo Schiavo
- Petra Cortright
- Pete Souza
- David Kennerly
- Joanie Lemercier
- Jim Krantz
- Joseph Mario Giordano
- James Danziger
- Peter Danziger
- Hoda Afshar
- Seydou Keïta
- Matthew Porter
- Tod Papageorge
- Esteban Mauchi
- David Hume Kennerly
- Deborah Willis
Institutions
- Danziger Gallery
- Ansel Adams Publishing Rights Trust
- Association of International Photography Art Dealers (Aipad)
- The Art Newspaper
- Ansel Adams Gallery
- Association of International Photography Art Dealers (AIPAD)
- Hyperallergic
- AIPAD
- Museum of Modern Art
- Stanford Copyright Renewals Database
- Ansel Adams Trust
- Park Avenue Armory
- PetaPixel
- ArtNews
- Adobe
- ARTnews
Locations
- New York
- United States
- Hernandez
- New Mexico
- US Highway 84
- New York City