ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Alejandro Zaera-Polo Responds to Ecuador's Culture Minister Over Museo Nacional de Quito Competition Controversy

opinion-review · 2026-07-31

Architect Alejandro Zaera-Polo, a member of the international jury for the Museo Nacional de Quito (MuNa) competition, addressed Ecuador's Minister of Culture, Luque, in an open letter on Arquine. He expressed his disapproval of the minister's choice to disregard the jury's decision in favor of an online poll involving approximately 50,000 voters, which accounted for only 15% of the outcome for the $100 million project. Zaera-Polo criticized the formation of a secondary jury comprised of real estate developers (Schwartzkopf, Nobis, Campana) involved in nearby tower constructions, questioning the winning design's technical aspects like structural integrity and drainage within a two-year timeframe. He also condemned the participation of three Pritzker Prize laureates, labeling it a decline in professional standards. Furthermore, he accused the government of masking manipulation in the online vote, invoking Walter Lippmann's 'phantom public' notion, and emphasized that the museum is a collective asset for all Ecuadorians, asserting that populism conflicts with expertise.

Key facts

  • Alejandro Zaera-Polo was a member of the international technical jury for the Museo Nacional de Quito (MuNa) competition.
  • The Ecuadorian government, led by Minister Luque, overruled the jury's decision based on an online vote of about 50,000 people, weighted at 15%.
  • The project budget is $100 million.
  • The winning design was chosen by a second jury composed of individuals working for real estate developers Schwartzkopf, Nobis, and Campana.
  • Zaera-Polo questions the technical feasibility of the winning design, including structural support, lighting, drainage, and constructability.
  • Three Pritzker Prize winners participated in the new process, which Zaera-Polo criticizes.
  • The museum holds 1.2 million patrimonial assets.
  • The letter was published on Arquine.
  • Zaera-Polo accuses the government of using 'citizen participation' as a facade, citing Walter Lippmann's 'phantom public'.
  • The online vote was allegedly manipulated by losing teams and their political voices.

Entities

Artists

  • Alejandro Zaera-Polo
  • Charles Jencks
  • Camillo Sitte
  • Walter Lippmann

Institutions

  • Arquine
  • Museo Nacional de Quito (MuNa)
  • Schwartzkopf
  • Nobis
  • Campana
  • Pritzker Prize

Locations

  • Quito
  • Ecuador
  • La Carolina

Sources