AI Boom Built on Shareholder Value Ideology, Warns Economist William Lazonick
In a detailed analysis published on Naked Capitalism, economist William Lazonick argues that the AI boom is being built on a corporate governance model that prioritizes shareholder value above all else, a system he has critiqued for decades. The article, written by Lynn Parramore of the Institute for New Economic Thinking, traces the historical shift from stakeholder capitalism to shareholder primacy, highlighting key moments such as the SEC's adoption of Rule 10b-18 in 1982, which legalized stock buybacks, and the influence of economists like Michael Jensen and Kevin Murphy in promoting stock-based executive pay. Lazonick's research shows that buybacks consumed 62% of corporate earnings by the late 2000s, diverting funds from wages, benefits, and innovation. He cites examples like Boeing, which spent $43 billion on buybacks from 2013 to 2019, contributing to safety lapses that led to two fatal 737 MAX crashes. The article also notes that Thomas Ferguson, Servaas Storm, and Jie Chen identified an unexpected drop in labor's share of GDP in 1999, predating the China shock, which they attribute to the shareholder value revolution. Lazonick warns that without serious corporate governance reform, AI will exacerbate inequality and undermine innovation, as the technology is being integrated into a system designed to extract value for shareholders at the expense of workers.
Key facts
- William Lazonick is an economist and business historian known for critiquing shareholder value ideology.
- The article was written by Lynn Parramore, Senior Research Analyst at the Institute for New Economic Thinking.
- Thomas Ferguson directs research at the Institute for New Economic Thinking and worked with Servaas Storm and Jie Chen on labor share data.
- The unexpected drop in labor's share of GDP occurred in 1999, before the China shock.
- SEC adopted Rule 10b-18 in 1982, legalizing open-market stock repurchases.
- Michael Jensen and Kevin Murphy popularized stock-based executive pay in 1990.
- Lazonick studied over 2,000 S&P 500 companies from 1981 to 2019, finding buybacks consumed 62% of corporate earnings by the late 2000s.
- Boeing spent about $43 billion on buybacks from 2013 to early 2019, leading up to two 737 MAX crashes that killed 346 people.
- Jack Welch, former GE chief, called shareholder value 'the dumbest idea in the world.'
- The article warns that AI will supercharge the problems of shareholder value capitalism.
Entities
Institutions
- Institute for New Economic Thinking
- Naked Capitalism
- Harvard Business School
- Standard Oil of New Jersey
- SEC
- Bloomberg
- Boeing
- IBM
- Intel
- Apple
- Walmart
- General Electric
- Pfizer
- Motorola
- HP
- Cisco
- General Motors
- Enron
- WorldCom
- Lucent
- ITT
Locations
- United States
- America