ARTFEED — Contemporary Art Intelligence

Ahlam Shibli's Dialectical Photography: Revealing and Disguising the Invisible

publication · 2026-04-22

In the 32nd issue of Afterall, published on 16 February 2013, Christian Höller analyzes Ahlam Shibli's photographic work, which both uncovers and conceals marginalized groups such as Palestinians in Israel, Bedouin trackers, LGBT individuals, Polish orphans, migrant traders in Turin, and care workers in Barcelona. Her notable series include 'Unrecognised' (2000), 'Goter' (2002–03), 'Trackers' (2005), 'Death' (2011–12), 'Eastern LGBT' (2006), 'Dom Dziecka' (2008), 'Market' (2005), 'Dependence' (2007), and 'Trauma' (2008–09). Shibli skillfully sidesteps victim-perpetrator dichotomies through spatial distancing and fragmented imagery. Curator Ulrich Loock emphasizes that the denial of basic rights also strips individuals of their 'right to their own photograph.' T.J. Demos points out that 'Trauma' complicates representational interpretations by intertwining narratives of Nazi atrocities and French colonial conflicts.

Key facts

  • Essay published in Afterall issue 32 on 16 February 2013
  • Ahlam Shibli born 1970 in Arab al-Shibli, Palestine
  • Shibli's photographic series include 'Unrecognised' (2000), 'Goter' (2002–03), 'Trackers' (2005), 'Death' (2011–12), 'Eastern LGBT' (2006), 'Dom Dziecka' (2008), 'Market' (2005), 'Dependence' (2007), 'Trauma' (2008–09)
  • Shibli describes photography as 'a practice of actively revealing and disguising at the same time'
  • Curator Ulrich Loock argues that denied fundamental rights necessitate denying the 'right to one's own photograph'
  • T.J. Demos notes 'frequent elisions, lacunae and fragmentations' in Shibli's work
  • Kamal Boulatta identifies three modes of spatial distancing in Shibli's work
  • 'Trauma' series addresses Nazi massacre in Tulle (1944) and French colonial wars

Entities

Artists

  • Ahlam Shibli
  • Christian Höller
  • Kamal Boulatta
  • Ulrich Loock
  • T.J. Demos
  • Mahmoud Abu Hashhash
  • Rhoda Kanaaneh
  • Lisette Lagnado
  • Adania Shibli

Institutions

  • Afterall
  • Ikon Gallery
  • Camera Austria
  • Darat al Funun — The Khalid Shoman Foundation
  • MACBA
  • Jeu de Paume
  • Museu de Arte Contemporânea de Serralves
  • Nafas Art Magazine
  • Leuven University Press
  • Verlag der Buchhandlung Walther König

Locations

  • Palestine
  • Israel
  • Jordan
  • Mount Tabor
  • Wadi Saleib
  • Arab al-Shibli
  • Galilee
  • Arab al-Sbaih
  • Mas'ha
  • Jericho
  • Tulle
  • Corrèze
  • France
  • Poland
  • Barcelona
  • Spain
  • Turin
  • Italy
  • Indochina
  • Algeria

Sources